[ cgl / con / g / mu / qa / w ] [ index / top / reports / FAQ / DAAS / IG / status / transparency / fuuka ] [ img-search ]
As Dark As My Soul Default Fuuka

/mu/ - Music (Temp full images)


View post   

File: 8 KB, 225x225, images.jpg [Show reposts] Image reverse search: [iqdb] [google]
54893452 No.54893452 [Reply] [Original]

What went wrong?

>> No.54893460

Nothing.

>> No.54893481

His best album to date.

>> No.54893488

>>54893452
>>54893460
>>54893481
He got too sad and as a result lacked the ambition to make a truly impressive album.

>> No.54893506

it's pretty good

>> No.54893811

>>54893452
his mother died

>> No.54893829

>>54893811
:(

>> No.54893859

someone please tell me saying this album is good is a meme, please

>> No.54894099
File: 185 KB, 1018x624, 1427553590056.jpg [Show reposts] Image reverse search: [iqdb] [google]
54894099

>>54893859
no... its a sad, but great album a solid 9/10

>> No.54894105
File: 762 KB, 587x439, 132432868472.png [Show reposts] Image reverse search: [iqdb] [google]
54894105

>>54893452
It ended eventually

>> No.54894153

>>54893452
Your taste in music

>> No.54894178

>>54893452
he decided to make an entire album modeled after The Sound of Silence's opening track

>> No.54894215

>>54893488
You're one of those people who thinks Age of Adz is anything other than unlistenable trash, don't you?

>> No.54894267

>>54893452
some of the songs are too simple. mostly great though

>> No.54894322

>>54894215
but age of adz is my favorite of his
c&l just doesn't hold up to something like benji imo

if you like it thats great man.

>> No.54894405

It's good but his other albums are way better.

>> No.54894679

>>54894322
gosh do you like death grips too

and benji is literally just boring prose in a disgusting accent over boring twing twangs. The lyrical structure and melodies in general are poorly thought out. I can appreciate the levelled delivery as a representation of the repression of emotion that society demands of men, but that doesn't make it emotionally or viscerally appealing any more than Age of Adz's level of brash experimentation does. The vulnerable, innocent, yet still guided delivery on C&L in the wake of his mother's death in particular compared to the gravelly, often trailing vocals found on Benji. The elegance of his twing twangs, so airy and light and thin that they invoke angelic harps heralding his mother's ascent to the heavens, compared to the lumbering lethargy of Kozelek's album. The emphasis on Sufjan's interpersonal relationships and actual, deep emotion compared to the detached, purely descriptive lyrics of Benji.

What these all add up to is that Benji, while it may be more conceptually interesting, completely lacks any melodic or emotional appeal. Fortunately, C&L has them in spades.

>> No.54894707

>>54894679
nop i hate death grips.
but thanks for the info good for you :)

>> No.54894761

>>54893452
Your dad didn't pull-out in time

>> No.54894798

>>54894322
This holds up fine to albums like benji but I don't really see the need for a comparison. Benji is more of straight telling you the facts over simple melodies while C&L focuses a bet more on abstract relations. I get their both personal albums but I see them both as good in their own rights.

>> No.54894868

>>54894215
That other guy wasn't me.
AOA is his 4th best.

>> No.54894906

>>54893859
We're only 4 months into 2015, but nothing else even comes close to this album's caliber. It'll be in the top 3 albums of 2015, for sure.

It's also his greatest album, which is saying a lot, because Seven Swans and Illinois are masterpieces in their own right.

>> No.54894925

>Cucktano only gave this a 7

What a fucking sperg.

>> No.54894975

>>54894322
>c&l just doesn't hold up to something like benji imo

Can you fucking memelords stop this aspie shit already. The two albums are not even remotely similar.

>> No.54895010
File: 48 KB, 424x597, 1427440525280.jpg [Show reposts] Image reverse search: [iqdb] [google]
54895010

>>54893452
sufjan stevens is the musical equivelent of a romantic comedy. Rom-coms aren't intrinsically bad, and some are actually pretty good...but why the fuck would you waste your time on it??

>> No.54895011

>>54894975
>>54894975
I SAID IMO
jesus no wonder anthony gets viewers when you retards can't read that this is my opinion not yours

i think they are similar, you don't have to
everybody is different

>> No.54895012

>>54894906
>but nothing else even comes close to this album's caliber.
The Ark Work
TPAB
TPTB
>It's also his greatest album
Explain why.

>> No.54895013

>>54894679
i found benji to be better than this. i don't know, benji is just an honest, realistic album. its like you were having a casual discussion with mark.

i love carrie and lowell to death, but sufjan throws a lot of lyrical cliches into the mix. like "every road leads to an end". god, like i haven't heard something like that before.

i hated benji when i first listened to it. now it's one of my favorite albums. c+l and benji can't really be compared though, they are pretty much completely different types of music. sufjan goes for that singer-songwriter sound, while mark is like "oh ill just 'sing' what im thinking."

after i wrote this i realized that there was no reason to reply to your post but i did not want this to go to waste so whatever

>> No.54895048

>>54895012
the bells and the unintelligable vocals ruined the ark work

>> No.54895114

>>54895048
The bells add a sacred tone to the album.
Also there are plenty albums that, without lyrics, are unintelligible.

>> No.54895309

>>54895114
>cluttered and rarely even on beat
>sacred
kek

>> No.54895389

>>54894153
underrated post

>> No.54895492

1. Bad hooks that work in reverse (shoulda wrote a lettaaaaaaaaa)
2. The masturbating lyric
3. Some of the melodies seem prototypical (title track)
4. Crap vocal effects (Death with Dignity)

It was a 7.5/10 on my first listen but I think it's really more of a 6.5.

>> No.54895506

>>54895309
>implying "the beat" is necessary in sacred music
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=EwV592ULRC8

>> No.54895537

>>54895492
>lettaaaaaaaaa
kek

>> No.54895735

>>54895309
>>54895048
>complaining about the bells

literally nobody had this complaint till it was fantano's main gripe with the whole album. they're not harsh at all and they're not high up enough in the mix to really matter if they're totally on beat. furthermore, it doesn't really matter if they're on beat, they're there for texture and to add a little bit of sound to the high end. even the most trebly of speakers (laptop speakers, earbuds) don't push the bells forward enough for them to be a really valid point to complain about on the album

>> No.54895768

>>54895735
sunbather and aesthetica > ark work

>> No.54895788

>>54895010
underrated post

>> No.54895805

>>54895768
i like all three personally, but the ark work is by far the most challenging and innovative of the three

>> No.54895826

objectively 4/10

>> No.54895940

>>54895768
No.

>> No.54895992

>>54895826
Memedrick Mememar fan detected.

>> No.54896067

>memerie and memewell
im feeling light 4 at best

>> No.54896240

i wish he would tear up my tender asshole and tell me about his childhood while stroking my cheek

>> No.54896557
File: 1.58 MB, 2485x2186, wince.jpg [Show reposts] Image reverse search: [iqdb] [google]
54896557

>>54896240

>> No.54896935

Does anyone have a Mega link for Michigan? I just got into Sufjan and can’t find a decent download link for it.

>> No.54897508

>>54896935
fuck off

>> No.54897563

>>54896935
If you've already tried the archive (from the sticky) let me know and I can hook you up.

>> No.54897622

>>54894679
You're an idiot by the way

>>
Name (leave empty)
Comment (leave empty)
Name
E-mail
Subject
Comment
Action