[ cgl / con / g / mu / qa / w ] [ index / top / reports / FAQ / DAAS / IG / status / transparency / fuuka ] [ img-search ]
As Dark As My Soul Default Fuuka

/mu/ - Music (Temp full images)


View post   

File: 283 KB, 747x504, genesis.jpg [Show reposts] Image reverse search: [iqdb] [google]
54662448 No.54662448 [Reply] [Original]

ITT: We rate an artist's discography

From Genesis to Revelation - 5/10
Trespass - 8/10
Nursery Cryme - 9/10
Foxtrot - 10/10
Selling England by the Pound - 9/10
The Lamb Lies Down on Broadway - 10/10
A Trick of the Tail - 10/10
Wind & Wuthering - 8/10
And Then There Were Three - 7/10
Duke - 8/10
Abacab - 5/10
Genesis - 8/10
Invisible Touch - 7/10
We Can't Dance - 6/10
Calling All Stations - 4/10

>> No.54662527

From Genesis to Revelation - 5/10
Trespass - 8/10
Nursery Cryme - 9/10
Foxtrot - 10/10
Selling England by the Pound - 9/10
The Lamb Lies Down on Broadway - 10/10
A Trick of the Tail - 9/10
Wind & Wuthering - 6/10
And Then There Were Three - 7/10
Duke - 6/10
Abacab - 7/10
Genesis - 5/10
Invisible Touch - 7/10
We Can't Dance - 3/10
Calling All Stations - 3/10

>> No.54662630
File: 100 KB, 800x494, image.jpg [Show reposts] Image reverse search: [iqdb] [google]
54662630

Pretty Hate Machine - 9/10
Broken - 7/10
The Downward Spiral - 10/10
The Fragile - 8/10
With Teeth - 5/10
Year Zero - 7/10
Ghosts - 6/10
The Slip - 8/10
Hesitation Marks - 6/10

>> No.54662765
File: 41 KB, 469x463, imma let you tip.jpg [Show reposts] Image reverse search: [iqdb] [google]
54662765

The College Dropout - 10/10
Late Registration - 9/10
Graduation - 8/10
808s - 7/10
MBDTF - 10/10
Yeezus - 6/10

>> No.54663966

>>54662630
Pretty Hate Machine - 4/10
Broken - 3/10
The Downward Spiral - 3/10
never managed to get further

>> No.54664312

Lost Dogs - a million
Ten - 10
Binaural - 9.5
Yield - 8
Vitalogy - 7.5
No Code - 6.75
Vs. - 6.5
Riot Act - 6.25
Self-Titled - 5.75
Lightning Bolt - 5.5
Backspacer - 5.5

>> No.54664339

>>54663966
>66
i rate these digits a 10/10

>> No.54664465
File: 22 KB, 499x430, 1425174952134.jpg [Show reposts] Image reverse search: [iqdb] [google]
54664465

>>54662527
>Wind & Wuthering - 6/10
>And Then There Were Three - 7/10

I'm legit curious about this

>> No.54664540
File: 599 KB, 1920x1080, image.jpg [Show reposts] Image reverse search: [iqdb] [google]
54664540

Liscense to ill - 7/10
Paul's boutique - 10/10
Check your head - 8/10
Ill communication - 7/10
Hello nasty - 6/10
To the five boroughs - 5/10
The mix up - 5/10
Hot sauce committee part 2 - 7/10

>> No.54664737

>>54664465
W&W has great playing but most of the songs just aren't that good. And the chorus of Your Own Special Way is the first truly awful thing they did.

>> No.54664862
File: 9 KB, 277x324, panda bear.jpg [Show reposts] Image reverse search: [iqdb] [google]
54664862

Spirit: 8/10
Danse Manatee: 5/10
Hollinndagain: 6/10
Campfire Songs: 4/10
Here Comes The Indian: 10/10
Sung Tongs: 7/10
Feels: 10/10
Strawberry Jam: 8/10
Merriweather: 8/10
ODDSAC: 6/10
Centipede Hz: 7/10

s/t: 5/10
Young Prayer: 6/10
Person Pitch: 8/10
Tomboy: 7/10
PBVTGR: 7/10

Pullhair Rubeye (normal): 3/10
Pullhair Rubeye (corrected): 7/10
Down There: 8/10
Enter the Slasher House: 7/10

>> No.54665975

Pablo Honey - 7/10
The Bends - 8/10
OK Computer - 10/10
Kid A - 10/10
Amnesiac - 8/10
Hail to the Thief - 7/10
In Rainbows - 6/10
The King of Limbs - 8/10

>> No.54666084

>>54664862
>Danse Manatee: 5/10
>Hollinndagain: 6/10
>Campfire Songs: 4/10
>Sung Tongs: 7/10
I can't dig this

>> No.54666178

>>54664737
Fair enough, Your Own Special Way is by far the worst track on W&W.

Sad thing is that it could have been replaced by Inside and Out, which was left out and put in an EP instead.

>> No.54666419
File: 55 KB, 412x479, i can phil it coming.jpg [Show reposts] Image reverse search: [iqdb] [google]
54666419

Face Value: 9/10
Hello, I Must be Going: 8/10
No Jacket Required: 7/10
But Seriously: 9/10
Both Sides: 7/10
Disney's Tarzan OST: 9/10
Everything else: 4/10

>> No.54667415
File: 17 KB, 240x271, ]tmbg.jpg [Show reposts] Image reverse search: [iqdb] [google]
54667415

S/T- 10/10
Lincoln- 10/10
Flood- 9/10
Apollo 18- 8.5/10
John Henry- 8/10
Factory Showroom- 9/10
Long Tall Weekend- 7/10
Mink Car- 5/10
The Spine- 7/10
The Else- 8/10
Join Us- 8.5/10
Nanobots- 8/10
then again I'm a huge fucking fanboy and have been listening to them forever. I don't really hate anything they've done

>> No.54668060
File: 201 KB, 317x275, 1425207073439.png [Show reposts] Image reverse search: [iqdb] [google]
54668060

>>54666419
>Disney's Tarzan OST: 9/10

Hell yes, that shit's fucking brilliant, one of my favorite Disney soundtracks.

>>54667415
>Nanobots- 8/10

Good thing I'm not the only one who liked Nanobots.

>> No.54668125

>>54662630
give year zero one more point and i'm on board with this

>> No.54668221

>Filth - 10/10
>Cop - 8/10
>Greed - 6.5/10
>Holy Money - 6.5/10
>PCIAGI - 10/10
>Children of God - 9/10
>The Burning World - 5/10
>White Light - 6/10
>Love of Life - 8/10
>The Great Annihilator - 6.5/10
>Soundtracks - 7/10
>MFWGMUARTTS - 6.5/10
>The Seer - 10/10
>To Be Kind - 9/10

>> No.54668431

>>54668221
good job overall, except the great annilhator deserves a much higher score than that

>> No.54668454

>>54662448
Peter Gabriel's Genesis 10/10
Phil Collins's Genesis 7/10

>> No.54668606

>>54668454
Pretty much.

Though I'd rate Collins-era Genesis an 8/10 because their albums until Duke are amazing prog efforts, even if Duke is sorta poppy. The other albums have their great moments such as Mama, Home by the Sea, No Son of Mine, etc, but as a whole they pale in comparison to Genesis' 70s material.

>> No.54668664
File: 127 KB, 1152x864, pixies-2.jpg [Show reposts] Image reverse search: [iqdb] [google]
54668664

Surfer Rosa - 9/10
Doolittle - 10/10
Bossanova - 7.5/10
Trompe le Monde - 7/10

not counting Indy Cindy because that's technically a compilation

>> No.54669903

The Smiths - 9/10
Meat is Murder - 7/10
The Queen is Dead - 10/10
Strangeways Here we Come - 9/10

>> No.54670186
File: 98 KB, 608x476, vu.jpg [Show reposts] Image reverse search: [iqdb] [google]
54670186

The Velvet Underground & Nico - 9/10
White Light/White Heat - 10/10
The Velvet Underground - 6/10
Loaded - 7/10
Squeeze - 1/10

>> No.54670255
File: 18 KB, 400x312, TheReplacements.jpg [Show reposts] Image reverse search: [iqdb] [google]
54670255

Sorry Ma, Forgot to Take the Trash Out 7/10
Stink 6/10
Hootenanny 5.5/10
Let it Be 8/10
Tim 9/10
Pleased to Meet Me 7.5/10
Don't Tell a Soul 6/10
All Shook Down 5/10

>> No.54670366
File: 30 KB, 687x234, Cocteau_Twins_promo_sheet.jpg [Show reposts] Image reverse search: [iqdb] [google]
54670366

Cocteau Twins

Garlands - 5
Head Over Heels - 8
Treasure - 9
Victorialand - 8
The Moon and Melodies - 6/10
Blue Bell Knoll - 8
Heaven or Las Vegas - 7
Four Calender Cafe - 6
Milk and Kisses - 5
Their EPs - Easily a 9, their EPs were ridiculously consistent and follow the above grades except maybe put every grade up one

>> No.54670622

>Animal Collective
Spirit, They're Gone, Spirit, They've Vanished - 10/10
Danse Manatee - 6/10
Hollinndagain - 7/10
Campfire Songs - 10/10
Here Comes the Indian - 9/10
Sung Tongs - 8/10
Feels - 10/10
Strawberry Jam - 8/10
Merriweather Post Pavilion - 9/10
ODDSAC - 9/10
Centipede Hz - 7/10

>Pink Floyd
The Piper At the Gates of Dawn - 5/10
A Saucerful of Secrets - 7/10
More - 6/10
Ummagumma - 7/10
Atom Heart Mother - 10/10
Meddle - 8/10
Obscured by Clouds - 7/10
The Dark Side of the Moon - 10/10
Wish You Were Here - 10/10
Animals - 9/10
The Wall - 6/10
The Final Cut - 3/10
A Momentary Lapse of Reason - 6/10
The Division Bell - 5/10
The Endless River - 6/10

>Mercury Rev
Yerself Is Steam - 9/10
Boces - 9/10
See You On the Other Side - 7/10
Deserter's Songs - 8/10
All Is Dream - 6/10
Secret Migration - 5/10
Snowflake Midnight - 5/10

>The Flaming Lips
Hear It Is - 5/10
Oh My Gawd!!!...The Flaming Lips - 6/10
Telepathic Surgery - 5/10
In a Priest-Driven Ambulance - 10/10
HIT to Death In the Future Head - 7/10
Transmissions From the Satellite Heart - 9/10
Clouds Taste Metallic - 9/10
Zaireeka - 9/10
The Soft Bulletin - 10/10
Yoshimi Battles the Pink Robots - 9/10
At War With the Mystics - 6/10
Once Beyond Hopelessness - 7/10
Embryonic - 8/10
The Dark Side of the Moon - 2/10
The Flaming Lips & Heady Fwends - 8/10
The Terror - 6/10
Peace Sword - 7/10
With a Little Help From My Fwends - 3/10

>> No.54670633

>>54670366
>heaven or las vegas
>not 10

>> No.54670664

>>54670622
>giving dsotm a 10
reddit: the post

>> No.54670721

>>54668664
>Come on Pilgrim - 11/10

>> No.54670741

>>54670664
>implying DSOTM isn't one of their best albums

>> No.54670771

>>54670622
>AnCo fan
>The Piper At the Gates of Dawn - 5/10

double pleb

>> No.54670825

>>54670633
>ohherewego
Heaven or Las Vegas is good pop album but in many ways it doesn't reflect Cocteau Twins' music very well. The albums songs are extremely streamlined to fit into a very rigid pop presentation, the lyrics are actual lyrics, the production is very pristine and slick but most of all Elizabeth sounds like she's been strangled, held back by this rigid pop structure.
I think there are some great moments on that album, certainly great tracks but this was very obviously Cocteau Twins break through album (after BBK, specifically Carolyn's Fingers) and Robin knew that so he made sure everything was as conventional as possible.

it's annoying as well because they really lost the plot after that album and their consistent strew of great releases just died down and fucked off.

>> No.54670851

>>54670741
i don't even have anything against that era of pink floyd but giving it a 10 is ridiculous

>> No.54670985

>>54670851
Yeah, that I can agree with

>> No.54671055

EP: 6/10
Exmilitary: 5/10
Money Store: 5.5/10
No Love Deep Web: 6.5/10
Government Plates: 4/10
Niggas on the Moon: 6.5/10
Jenny Death: 4/10

>> No.54671096
File: 25 KB, 600x391, Moz.jpg [Show reposts] Image reverse search: [iqdb] [google]
54671096

Viva Hate - 10/10
Kill Uncle - 4/10
Your Arsenal - 7/10
Vauxhall and I - 9/10
Southpaw Grammar - 4/10
Maladjusted - 2/10
You are the Quarry - 6/10
Ringleader of the Tormentors - 7/10
Years of Refusal - 8/10
World Peace is None of Your Business - 5/10

>> No.54671097

>>54671055
>thank you for joining me in my jounrey to whip the Death Grips fags out of /mu/ one post at a time :^)

>> No.54671337
File: 16 KB, 530x353, a073723c39e35b9f9c85a409d310f987.jpg [Show reposts] Image reverse search: [iqdb] [google]
54671337

>Incunabula
Hard to listen to, mildly uninteresting and generally dull
>Amber
More interesting, though still difficult to finish
>Tri Repetae
Beautiful; an absolutely gorgeous masterpiece
>Chiastic Slide
Significantly worse than Tri Repetae; around the same level as Amber, or maybe a bit worse. Cichli is the only song worth listening to in my opinion.
>LP5
Incredible recovery from Chiastic Slide. Definitely equivalent to Tri Repetae in quality with an exciting new sound and more diversity in tracks.
>ep7
Not as consistently good as LP5, but just as interesting, if not more. It has moments that are better than LP5 but also some that are worse. Overall, it isn't as good as LP5, but it also isn't meant to me. It's sonically fascinating and aesthetically pleasant to listen to. The experimentation shifts focus from rhythm to sound in general.
>Confield
A much larger step in the direction taken with ep7; the sound is loaded with strange effects and every song has unfathomable amounts of detail put into it.
>Draft 7.30
Much more rhythmic than any previous album. The drum patterns are constantly changing and never stick around long enough to be fully absorbed. The detail here is unbelievable and provides endless deconstruction with every listen.
>Untilted
A continuation of Draft 7.30, just as rhythmic but this time so complex it can't even be deciphered. The rhythms get so complex that individual sounds are no longer present. Instead, the drums mold together into one thick layer. This album never gets old.

Continued in the next post.

>> No.54671385
File: 338 KB, 1536x1024, autechre.jpg [Show reposts] Image reverse search: [iqdb] [google]
54671385

>>54671337
>Quaristice
This one is patchy. It has moments that are interesting but it also has a lot of tracks that completely turn me off. It's surprising how many uninteresting tracks there are on this one considering how much good material was thrown onto the secondary releases.
>Oversteps
This one is a lot more accessible and honestly less groundbreaking than previous albums. It feels like a "back to the roots" album, which isn't necessarily a bad thing, but I don't find myself listening to it often.
>Exai
I don't even know what to say about this one. It has more detail than I'll ever be able to comprehend. Not suitable for pleasure listening, but the perfect album for active listening. I've never been so perplexed by any other album ever.I could listen to it endlessly with a very different experience each time. Not necessarily their best work, but their most abstract.

>> No.54671912

S/T - 8/10
Come My Fanatics - 10/10
Supercoven - 7/10
Dopethrone - 11/10
Let Us Prey - 6/10
We Live - 7/10
Witchcult Today - 9/10
Black Mass - 7/10
Time to Die - 8/10

>> No.54672197

>>54671097
I am a "Death Grips fag," just because someone is a fan doesn't mean every release is a 10/10, in fact it's exactly the opposite. A 5 is an alright album and a 4 isn't that bad by any means. I don't operate on the IGN 8.5-10 scale

>> No.54672248

>>54672197
>a 4 isn't bad by any means

As far as I know, 5 is average and 4 is already into bad territory.

>> No.54672330

>>54665975
>in rainbows
>higher than KoL

>> No.54672359

>>54672330
In Rainbows isn't higher than KoL, though.

>> No.54672495

>>54670186
Banana Underground 9/10
White Light/White Heat 10/10
The Velvet Underground 8/10
Loaded 8/10
Squeeze 1-2/10

Seriously how did David Yule fuck up that bad on Squeeze? Seriously? He had legit good songs on self titled 2 and Loaded.

>> No.54672560

>Led Zeppelin
I 10/10
II 9/10
III 8/10
IV 8/10
Houses of the Holy 9/10
PG 9/10
Presence 7/10
ITtoD 6/10
CODA 6/10

>> No.54672584

>>54672359
sorry i forgot to say
>not higher than KoL

>> No.54672673

>Bon Iver
For Emma, Forever Ago: 8/10
Blood Bank: 7/10
Bon Iver: 10/10

>> No.54672888

WEEN:
GodWeenSatan: The Oneness - 7/10
The Pod - 8/10
Pure Guava - 8.5/10
Chocolate and Cheese - 5.5/10
12 Golden Country Greats - 6.5/10
The Mollusk - 6.5/10
Craters of the Sac - 4.5/10
White Pepper - 3.5/10
Quebec - 6/10
Shinola, Vol. 1 - 4.5/10
La Cucaracha - 5/10

Boredoms:
Osorezan no Stooges Kyo - 6.5/10
Soul Discharge - 6/10
Pop Tatari - 7.5/10
Super Roots - 5/10
Chocolate Synthesizer - 5.5/10
Super Roots 2 - 6/10
Super Roots 3 - 6/10
Super Roots 5 - 5.5/10
Super Roots 6 - 7/10
Super æ - 9.5/10
Super Roots 7 - 5.5/10
Vision Creation Newsun - 10/10
Seadrum/House of Sun - 8/10
Super Roots - 5.5/10
Super Roots 10 - 7.5/10

Black Moth Super Rainbow:
Falling Through a Field - 7.5/10
Start a People - 7/10
Dandelion Gum - 7.5/10
Eating Us - 5.5/10
Cobra Juicy - 4.5/10

>> No.54672926

s/t: 4/10
Static Prevails: 7/10
Clarity: 9.5/10
Bleed American: 8/10
Futures: 4/10
Chase This Light: 7.5/10
Invented: 5.5/10
Damage: 4.5/10

>> No.54672946

>>54666419
Well at least Dance Into the Light has one good song

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=q3IFGF21aBI

>> No.54673022

>>54665975
Pablo Honey - 5/10
The Bends - 8.5/10
OK Computer - 7.5/10
Kid A - 9/10
Amnesiac - 7/10
Hail to the Thief - 7/10
In Rainbows - 7.5/10
The King of Limbs - 8.5/10

>> No.54673128

>>54672888
"Chocolate Synthesizer" was a 10/10 for me.

>> No.54673161

>>54668664

>bossanova higher than trompe le monde

I respect your opinion but I disagree.

>> No.54673208

this should be fun
yes - 8.5
time and a word - 7
the yes album - 8
fragile - 7.5
close to the edge - 9
tales from topographic oceans - 6.5
relayer - 10
going for the one - 9
tormato - 8.5
drama - 8.5
90125 - 6
big generator - 6.5
onion - 6
talk - 5.5
keys to ascension 1 and 2 - 4.5
open your eyes - 3
the ladder - 8.5
magnification - 6.5
fly from here - 6
heaven and earth - 4.5

>>54662448
i'm genuinely impressed with your music taste; i never see people discuss genesis on here, let alone good things about collins era genesis. this is essentially my opinion, except atott and w&w are both 9s.

>>54663966
the fragile is actually pretty good
>>54666419
face value is a perfect ten imo
no jacket, but seriously, hello, and both sides are all 8s.

>>54668664
purple tape - 7
come on pilgrim - 7
surfer - 8
doolittle - 8
bossanova - 7
trompe - 8
indie cindy - 7

>> No.54673335

>>54673128
I definitely feel like it'll grow on me

>> No.54673417

>Steven Paul Taylor
Banana Bike - 8/10
The Old Album - 9/10
You Sweaty Thing - 8/10
The New Album - 8/10
Heaven Is a Zipper Away - 5/10
Trike & the Vikings - 7/10
SLAPPED - 7/10
Beat the World Up - 7/10
People Tonight - 4/10

>Be Brave Bold Robot
Be Brave Bold Robot - 8/10
Take a Deep Breath - 9/10
Under a Thin Veil of Madness - 7/10
Press E to Continue - 5/10

>John Ludington
Three From the Circle - 8/10
Some Glitter - 9/10
Clouds Today - 10/10
Attic Window - 8/10
Finn - 8/10

>> No.54673445

>>54673208

>fragile 7.5
>tormato - 8.5

dear god, what the hell is the matter with you

>> No.54673466

>>54673445
i think being overexposed to fragile ruined it for me
it got kind of boring after a while

>> No.54673483

>>54662448

Call it maaagic.

>> No.54673547

>>54673208
I like both incarnations of Genesis, though I do have a slight preference on Peter Gabriel era. It's funny because I used to dislike the Phil Collins era immensely and blast every album they made after Wind & Wuthering, but as I started to listen more the albums grew a lot on me and I started to like ATTWT, Duke and the self-titled a lot more than I used to. Invisible Touch and We Can't Dance have their moments as well.

My top 5 nowadays is:

1- The Lamb
2- Foxtrot
3- Trick of the Tail
4- Selling England
5- Nursery Cryme

>> No.54673586
File: 18 KB, 264x292, 1426554387117.jpg [Show reposts] Image reverse search: [iqdb] [google]
54673586

>>54673208
I'd rate Close to the Edge a 10 and Fragile a 9, but you're alright.

>> No.54673672

>>54669903
Meat Is Murder should be at least an 8, otherwise this is pretty correct. I've always considered it equal to the s/t in terms of quality.

>> No.54673686

>>54673547
i liked wind and wuthering better than trick tbh even with your own special way
i also take b sides and outtakes and stuff into an account b/c i collect a lot of bootlegs and stuff of that nature
frankly, the lamb and duke had the best outtakes imo

but anyway i could never rate them based on the fact that theyre perfect for different situations

>> No.54673831

>>54672926
Give one point from BA and point from the self-titled to Futures and this is accurate. To expand upon this

Jimmy Eat World EP: 9/10 (best overall after Clarity)
Stay On My Side Tonight EP: 7.5/10

>> No.54673876

>>54673686
I have some of the extra tracks here, but I only remember Inside and Out, Open Door, Evidence of Autumn and Twilight Alleyhouse.

Maybe I should pay more attention to them.

>> No.54673937

>>54673876
Duuude Twilight Alehouse is the best Genesis B-Side. I always forget about that song as I haven't listened to Genesis for a while.

>> No.54673972

Waiter You Vultures - 7.5/10
Church Mouth - 8.5/10
Censored Colors - 10/10
Satanic Satanist - 8/10
American Ghetto - 6.5/10
In The Mountain In The Cloud - 9/10
Evil Friends - 5/10

>> No.54674017

S/T - 6/10
Ride The Skies - 9/10
Wonderful Rainbow - 9.5/10
Hypermagic Mountain - 7/10
Earthly Delights - 8/10
Oblivion Hunter - 7/10
Fantasy Empire - 9/10

>> No.54674037

>>54673876
oh no ive got some really good shit
off the top of my head

>like, 6 different versions of fgtr
>live recording from nursery cryme days
>several studio outtakes from foxtrot and selling, including silver song and only your love etc
>several studio outtakes from the lamb
>every release of spot the pigeon available
>two releases of 3x3-- a picture disc and the regular release
>tfw no twilight alehouse or happy the man on 7"
>https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=M_5Jj5_0bq4 as a b side to your own special way
>almost all of the abacab, duke, genesis, and invisible touch singles on 7" and 12"
>various live bootlegs throughout the ages including six of the best

never bothered after invisible touch to get anything, i could send you some hq rips at some point if you give me an email address or last fm or something

>> No.54674040

>>54673937
Yeah, it's my favorite B-Side as well, Inside and Out being a close second.

My "version" of Wind & Wuthering actually has Your Own Special Way replaced with Inside and Out, and Twilight Alehouse is included in Selling England after I Know What I Like.

>> No.54674045

Blue Cadet-3 Do You Connect? - 5/10
Sad Sappy Sucker - 6/10
Long Drive - 9.5/10
Interstate 8 - 8.5/10
TLCW - 9/10
The Fruit That Ate Itself - 8/10
Night On The Sun EP - 6.5/10
BNOOS - 9/10
TM&A - 8.5/10
Everywhere And His Nasty Parlour Tricks - 7/10
Good News - 6.5/10
We Were Dead - 7.5/10
No One's First - 7.5/10
Strangers - bored/10

>> No.54674056
File: 188 KB, 500x500, Walmart_Associate_Choir_Swans.jpg [Show reposts] Image reverse search: [iqdb] [google]
54674056

>>54668221
I don't really agree with all of this but I respect your opinion.

> Filth - 9/10
> Cop - 8/10
> Greed - 7/10
> Holy Money - 7/10
> Children of God - 10/10
> The Burning World - 6/10
> White Light From the Mouth of Infinity - 8/10
> Love of Life - 7.5/10
> The Great Annihilator - 8/10
> Soundtracks for the Blind - 10/10
> My Father - 6.5/10
> The Seer - 10/10
> To Be Kind - 9/10

>> No.54674079

>>54674017
Lightning Bolt is great but their albums aren't that good man, it's hard for me to believe a true fan would rate them that highly if they had ever seen them live, and if you haven't seen them live then you've missed 95% of what they are about.

>> No.54674099
File: 81 KB, 259x383, huh.jpg [Show reposts] Image reverse search: [iqdb] [google]
54674099

>>54670622
> The Wall - 6/10

>> No.54674146
File: 16 KB, 400x270, nauseated lesbian.jpg [Show reposts] Image reverse search: [iqdb] [google]
54674146

>>54674056
>My Father - 6.5/10

>> No.54674154

>>54674037
I'm interested in the NC live recordings, the outtakes from Foxtrot and Selling England and Spot the Pigeon releases.

g512530@trbvm.com

>> No.54674171

>>54674099
C'mon anon. It's not hip to like their most popular album regardless of it's quality. Duh.

>> No.54674209

>>54674146
Okay fine, I'll bump it up to a 7. It's a good album, but it still feels like more of an Angels of Light album than a Swans album, save for a few delicious moments.

>> No.54674212

>>54674079
They are legit my favorite band in the world, my ratings are probably heavily skewed. Also I am going to see them live later this year, I have been wanting to do that for forever, as I never have.
Also I think Gibson's playing on some songs sort of make up for the weaker tracks (why they ever thought Birdy was a good song is beyond me), but yeah, I sort of agree that the earlier albums could be better "albums."

>> No.54674221

>>54674171
i feel like dsotm is deinitely their most popular

>> No.54674235

>>54674171
Oh right, I forgot we were on /mu/

>> No.54674339

>>54674171
It's not their most popular, and it's not that good.

>> No.54674350
File: 478 KB, 1060x1600, tumblr_mz2w7muyIj1r4g95fo1_1280.jpg [Show reposts] Image reverse search: [iqdb] [google]
54674350

Self titled - 4/10
Space oddity- 6/10
The man who sold the world - 6/10
Hunky dory - 9/10
Ziggy stardust - 8/10
Pinups - 3/10
Aladdin sain - 7/10
Diamond dogs - 6/10
Young Americans - 7/10
Stationtostation - 8/10
Low - 10/10
Heroes - 10/10
Lodger - 6/10
Scary Monsters - 10/10
Let's dance - 4/10
Tonight - 5/10
Never let me down - 6/10
Black tie white noise - 7/10
Buddha of suburbia - 9/10
Outside - 7/10
Earthling - 9/10
Hours - 5/10
Heathen - 8/10
Reality - 6/10
The next day - 7/10
Nothing has changed - 8/10

>> No.54674368

13 Songs - 8/10
Repeater - 9/10
Steady Diet of Nothing - 7/10
In on the Kill Taker - 8.5/10
Red Medicine - 10/10
End Hits - 8/10
The Argument - 10/10
Furniture EP - 8/10

>> No.54674441

>>54668221
>>54674056
Let me help you both:
>Filth - 8/10
>Cop - 5/10
>Greed - 5/10
>Holy Money - 5/10
>Children of God - 8.5/10
>The Burning World - 3/10
>White Light From the Mouth of Infinity - 8.5/10
>Love of Life - 6/10
>The Great Annihilator - 8/10
>Soundtracks to the Blind - 9/10
>My Father... - 6/10
>The Seer - 9/10
>To Be Kind - 9/10

>> No.54674465

>>54674154
sent! didnt have any live recordings on my computer at this time, email explains.

>> No.54674515

>>54662448
Radiohead
>Pablo honey: 5/10
>the bends: 5.5/10
>okc: 7/10
>kid a: 8/10
>amnesiac: 8/10
>httt: 5/10
>in rainbows: 6/10
>king of limbs: 5/10

>Vu & nico: 9.5/10
>wl/WH: 9/10
>Vu s/t: 5/10
>loaded: 4/10
>squeeze: lol/10

>piper: 9/10
>a saucerful: 7.5/10
>more: 5.5/10
>ummagumma: 8/10
>atom heart mother: 7/10
>meddle: 6/10
>obscured by clouds: 3/10
>dark side of the moon: 5.5/10
>wish you were here: 7/10
>animals: 6/10
>the wall: 4/10
>the final cut: 4/10
>momentary lapse of reason: 3/10
>the division bell: 4.5/10
>endless river: 2/10

>> No.54674527

>>54673161
I may have a bit of a bias because Bossanova is noisier

>> No.54674570

>>54674465

that's a lie they didnt finish uploading to dropbox
expect them in the next 15 minutes, its around 1.5 gb compressed

>> No.54674625
File: 309 KB, 828x1562, cartoon-pirate-01.jpg [Show reposts] Image reverse search: [iqdb] [google]
54674625

>>54674515
wow unpopular opinions ahoy!

>> No.54674640
File: 1.70 MB, 400x285, fugazi2.gif [Show reposts] Image reverse search: [iqdb] [google]
54674640

Fugazi
>13 Songs 7/10
>Repeater + 3 Songs 9/10
>Steady Diet Of Nothing 7/10
>In On The Kill Taker 10/10
>Red Medicine 10/10
>Instrument Soundtrack 8/10 (really fucking cool demos on this)
>End Hits 8/10
>Furniture 6/10
>The Argument 8/10
inflated ratings

>> No.54674661

>>54674640
oh fuck
>First Demo 7/10

>> No.54674683

>>54674570
No problem, I can extend the 10minutemail time.

Thanks, dude.

>> No.54674691

>>54674625
I'm not a fucking pleb and I recognize shit albums unlike plens who inflate things like no other

>> No.54674799

Telephono - 6/10
A Series of Sneaks - 6.5/10
Girls Can Tell - 7.5/10
Kill the Moonlight - 8.5/10
Gimme Fiction - 7.5/10
Ga x5 - 8/10
Transference - 6/10
They Want My Soul - 7/10

one of the best and most underrated rock bands of the last 20 years

>> No.54674951

The Red Hot Chili Peppers - 6/10
Freaky Styley - 8/10
The Uplift Mofo Party Plan - 7/10
Mother's Milk - 8.5/10
Blood Sugar Sex Magik - 8/10
One Hot Minute - 8.5/10
Californication - 8/10
By The Way - 7/10
Stadium Arcadium - 4/10
I'm With You - 2/10

>> No.54674999

>>54672560
Dad don't you have a shed to build somewhere?

>> No.54675086

>>54674683

just in case you didnt get those emails-- https://www.dropbox.com/s/4szv5s89i8pnpw3/outtakes.zip?dl=0 -- outtakes
https://www.dropbox.com/s/nejifpeogsfqxrh/spot%20the%20pigeon%20vinyl%20rip%202012.zip?dl=0 -- 2012 vinyl remaster of spot the pigeon
https://www.dropbox.com/s/vism8y8pjaetj94/spot%20the%20pigeon%20vinyl%20rip%20original.zip?dl=0 -- original vinyl rip of stp

>> No.54675114
File: 28 KB, 500x375, le bearded new jersey man of low fidelity and little to no talent.jpg [Show reposts] Image reverse search: [iqdb] [google]
54675114

the airing of grievances - 7/10
the monitor - 10/10
local business - 6/10

>> No.54675145

>>54664312
underrated post

>> No.54675361

>>54665975
>>54674515
>>54673022
Pablo Honey 4/10
The Bends 5/10
OK Computer 8/10 (10/10 in feels tho)
Kid A 9/10
Amnesiac 9.5/10
Hail to the Thief 8/10
In Rainbows 6/10
The King of Limbs 10/10

also,
The Eraser 8.5/10
AMOK 10/10
Tomorrow's Modern Boxes idk-what-the-fuck-he-was-doing/10

>> No.54675367
File: 48 KB, 600x392, pixies.jpg [Show reposts] Image reverse search: [iqdb] [google]
54675367

>>54668664
sufer rosa - 9/10
doolittle - 9/10
bossanova - 7/10
trompe le monde - 6/10

>>54669903
the smiths - 9/10
meat is murder - 9/10
the queen is dead - 10/10
strangeways 7/10
hatful of hollow - 9/10
louder than bombs - 9/10

>>54670186
the velvet underground and nico - 9/10
white light/white heat - 6/10
the velvet underground - 8/10
loaded - 7/10
squeeze - meme/10

>>54671055
exmilitary - 8/10
the money store - 7/10
no love deep web - 6/10
government plates - 7/10
niggas on the moon - 6/10
jenny death - 8/10

>> No.54675388
File: 98 KB, 271x246, wine butler.png [Show reposts] Image reverse search: [iqdb] [google]
54675388

funeral - 9/10
neon bible - 9/10
the suburbs - 6/10
reflektor - 5/10

>>54662765
college dropout - 9/10
late registration - 9/10
graduation - 7/10
808s - 7/10
MBDTF - 10/10
yeezus - 9/10

>>54664862
spirit - 8/10
danse - 3/10
campfire songs - 5/10
here comes the indian - 6/10
sung tongs - 5/10
feels - 7/10
strawberry jam - 8/10
merriweather post pavilion - 6/10
centipede hz - 4/10

>>54665975
pablo honey - 2/10
the bends - 8/10
OK computer - 9/10
kid A - 9/10
amnesiac - 8/10
hail to the thief - 8/10
in rianbows - 9/10
the king of limbs - 6/10

>>54668221
filth - 4/10
children of god - 5/10
the burning world - 2/10
white light - 7/10
love of life - 5/10
the great annihilator - 8/10
soundtracks for the blind - 6/10
my father... - 5/10
to be kind - 7/10
i need to finish their catalog

>> No.54675450

Scott - 8/10
Scott 2 - 9.5/10
Scott 3 - 9/10
Scott 4 - 10/10
Til the Band Comes In - 7.5/10
The Moviegoer - 5.5/10
Any Day Now - 5/10
Stretch - 6/10
We Had It All - 4/10
Nite Flights (Scott's songs) - 10/10
Climate of Hunter - 8.5/10
Tilt - 9/10
The Drift - 10/10
And Who Shall Go To The Ball? And What Shall Go To The Ball? - 6.5/10
Bish Bosch - 9/10
Soused - 9.5/10

>> No.54675522

Pablo Honey - 7

The Bends - 8

OK Computer - 10

Kid A - 10

Amnesiac - 9.5

Hail to the Thief - 8.5

In Rainbows - 9.5

The King of Limbs - 9

>> No.54675543

Von - 7.5
Agaetis Byrjun - 9
( ) - 9.5
Takk... - 9.5
Hvarf Heim - 8.5
Meo Sud - 7.5
Valtari - 9
Kveikur - 8

>> No.54675567

Milk Eyed Mender - 9
Ys - 10
Have One On Me - 8.5

>> No.54675691

>Pink Floyd
The piper at the Gates of Dawn - 8.9/10
A Saucerful of Secrets - 8.5/10
More - 7.8/10
Ummagumma - 8/10
Atom Heart Mother - 8.5/10
Meddle - 9.5/10
Obscured by clouds - 6.5/10
Live at Pompeii - 9.6/10
The Dark Side of the Moon - 9.99999/10
Wish You Where Beer - 9.4/10
Animals - 9.1/10
The Wall - 8.9/10
The Final Cut - 5/10
A Momentary Lapse of Reason - 7.5/10
The Division Bell - 7.8/10
P.U.L.S.E. - 8/10
The Endless River - 8.9/10

>> No.54675725
File: 206 KB, 500x333, mothers.png [Show reposts] Image reverse search: [iqdb] [google]
54675725

Freak Out!: 10/10
Absolutely Free: 8.5/10
We're Only in it for the Money: 9/10
Cruising with Ruben and the Jets: 5.5/10
Uncle Meat: 9.5/10
Burnt Weeny Sandwich: 8/10
Weasels Ripped My Flesh: 9.5/10
The Grand Wazoo: 8/10
Over Nite Sensation: 8/10
One Size Fits All: 7.5/10

>> No.54675747
File: 48 KB, 400x462, 1426889375513.jpg [Show reposts] Image reverse search: [iqdb] [google]
54675747

slanted & enchanted - 7/10
crooked rain, crooked rain - 8.5/10
wowee zowee - 10/10
brighten the corners - 9/10
terror twilight - 8/10

s/t - 6/10
pig lib - 8.5/10
face the truth - nah/10
real emotional trash - 8/10
mirror traffic - 7.5/10
wig out at jagbags - 7/10

>> No.54675762

>>54662765
The College Dropout - 9/10
Late Registration - 11/10
Graduation - 6/10
808s & Heartbreak - 9/10
My Beautiful Dark Twisted Fantasy - 8/10
Yeezus - 8/10

>> No.54675770

exmilitary - 8/10
the money store - 7.5/10
no love deep web - 8.5/10
government plates - 8.5/10
the powers that b - 9/10

>> No.54675827
File: 68 KB, 600x337, BznOhf_CYAES8wx.jpg [Show reposts] Image reverse search: [iqdb] [google]
54675827

Death Grips - 7/10
ExMilitary - 7/10
The Money Store - 7/10
No Love Deep Web - 8/10
Government Plates - 8.5/10
The Powers That B - 9/10

NoTM is 10/10 IMO, and Jenny is 9/10.

>> No.54675868

>>54668221
>>Filth - 7/10
>>Cop - 8/10
>>Greed - 6/10
>>Holy Money - 7/10
>>PCIAGI - 8/10
>>Children of God - 6/10
>>The Burning World - 5/10
>>White Light - 8/10
>>Love of Life - 7/10
>>The Great Annihilator - 7/10
>>Soundtracks - 10/10
>>MFWGMUARTTS - 7/10
>>The Seer - 9/10
>>To Be Kind - 10/10

My favorite band.

>> No.54675926

>>54674515
>Dark side of the moon
>5.5

Try Harder

>> No.54675980

>Personal Rankings
STGSTV 10/10
Danse Manatee 7.5/10
Campfire Songs 8.5/10
Hollinndagain 7/10
Here Comes the Indian 8.5/10
Sung Tongs 10/10
Feels 9.5/10
Strawberry Jam 7/10
MPP 9.5/10
Centipede Hz 7/10

>> No.54676031

I forgive We Can't Dance because it has No Son Of Mine, Jesus He Knows Me, Driving The Last Spike, Dreaming While You Sleep, Living Forever and Fading Lights. These songs make me prefer this album over Invisible Touch and Abacab, especially Fading Lights.

The rest is pure filler shit to unnecessarily pad the album, they should have been B-sides at best.

>>
Name (leave empty)
Comment (leave empty)
Name
E-mail
Subject
Comment
Action