do any of these deserve a 10/10 tbh?
>>54449642Swans does, rest is memerap shite
I don't think so
He's prepping /mu/ for TPTB not getting a 10 with this post.
>>54449660None of the albums from this decade so far deserve a 10/10.This is coming from a person who's heard roughly 50 albums from each year since the year 1970.
>>54449660Swans deserves 6.5 To Be Branca is highly derivative of the ascension.TMS is a 8.5
>do any of these records deserve an arbitrary subjective "score" based on a non standard numerical scale created for the purpose of quantifying a single person's particular opinion which in no way should be taken as the meat of their opinion above their actual statements on the qualities of the music itself
TBK did
>>54449642I would say so. Would you disagree? Why?
>>54449660>To Be Kind >10 holy shit terrible terrible tate but then again this is europoor hours
>>54449683All of those albums deserve a 10/10, coming from a guy who has listened to hundreds of albums from each of the years those albums were released.Stop flexing and realize who you're talking about
jenny death when
>>54449676But TPAB already got a 10
>>54449711>To Be Kind >not a 10holy shit terrible terrible tate but then again this is europoor hours
>>54449726FLEX YOUR MUSCLES
>>54449728
>>54449698>Writing that downI don't think autists like you should listen to music. Can you even properly emphasize?
>>54449732Not even soundtracks is a 10 you retard. Stop having shit taste and stop inflating scores
>>54449769I empathise with opinions anon, not numbers :^)
Swans 8/10Kendrick 9/10Death Grips 6/10
>>54449793Yeah. I'm just waiting for the black metal records to come in the mail. So I'm a little on edge
I can't see a reason for why they'll be 10/10. When I think of 10/10 albums I think of stuff like Pet Sounds, Sgt Pepper, Highway 61, MPP, Ys, TVU&N, Let It Bleed, Spiderland. Albums that are good in many differet ways and you can just write paragraphs on why they're so good. I don't see enough quality in those 3 albums that would generate that.
>>54449683>le wrong generation
>>54449642They aren't personally tens for meTens of the last few years for me:Richard Dawson - Nothing ImportantClipping - CLPPNGDrones - I See SeaweedBut I rate them very highly and don't mind them getting a 10.
>>54449854I see seaweed was incredible... but "a moat you can stand in" and "why write a letter that you'll never send" really stick out to me as just not on the same level of quality, or even the same mood as the rest of the album, so I could never call it a 10/10 as a whole cohesive record
>>54449790>Not even soundtracks is a 10 you retardholy shit terrible terrible tate but then again this is europoor hours
>>54449893>"why write a letter that you'll never send"that's the best song though
>>54449893Maybe "A Moat You Can Stand In" was slightly weak but "Why Write a Letter That You'll Never Send" honestly almost instantly became one of my favourite songs of all time. It's bloody amazing.
>>54449683this is coming from a fedoraclad gentleman
>>54449854Wow shit tasteClipping? Are you 12?
>>54449854>Clipping - CLPPNGlol no fucking way is that a to it's 7/10 at best and this is from a massive hip hop fan>Drones - I See Seaweedlove this band but honestly it's 8/10
>>54449790but cop is :^))
>>544499508/10
>>54449908>>54449923to me it just seemed like a really unnecessary callback to songs they had previously written on records like gala mill, wait long by the river, and even liddiard's solo albumit's not a bad song by any means, but it didn't sit well on that album for me, and honestly they have done the same spaciously arranged lyrically focused mellow vibe much better in the past
>>54449854>Clipping - CLPPNG>10Objective pleb pls stop posting.
>>54449642That faggot>The 10s club!shut the fuck up
the only listenable album there is the kendrick one, it's certainly not amazing thoughthe rest are legit 0/10
>>54449854IT'S THE LAST SONG OF THE NIIIIIIIIGHT
>>54449660swans is about as big of a meme you can get outside of hip-hop>guys guys it has droning guitars>HOLY FUCKING SHIT WHAT A MASTERPIECE 10/10
>>54450074excellent critique
>>54449642Nope. They're all 9's at best.
>>54450143Cept swans which is a 7.5 at best
>>54450005>TMS3/10>TBK4/10TPAB>7/10none are the artists best work
>>54450005Please enlighten us then. What music do you like?
friendly reminder that 10s don't exist
>>54450181>except jd and exmftfy anon
At the time, giving the Money Store a 10 was appropriate. I think DG have released numerous albums that are better than it, however.To Be Kind is on the exact same level as the Seer, yet only one of them is considered a 10 by melonTo Pimp a Butterfly is a solid 6 or 7, but is has some really worthwhile tracks that I would individually give a 9 or 10
>>54450165contrarian
>>54450166lots of stuffbeen listening mostly to bark psychosis, julian cope and nobukazu takemura these past days
>>54449642not even close. tbk and tms are 8/10 at best and tpab is a 3/10
>>54449642Jesus christ, he is literally /mu/ personified.
>>54451550>thread full of people disagreeing>somehow he's the personification of /mu/Maybe if he had an iq of below 50. And even then, he'd only be a personification of you.
>>54449642>sticker over the titsconfirmed idiot
>>54449642TPAB has the most retarded lyrics I've heard this year.TBK is an 8 and TMS a 9 to me.
>>54449642they're all 8s
>>544513343/10 lmao
>>54449660You really thing TBK is a 10? Can you explain why?
>>54450015DON'T FORGET TO TIP THE BARTENDERYOU GOT FUCKED UP THAT'S ALLLRRRIGHHHTT
>>54449936>>54449987What's /mu/'s problem with Clipping?
>>54450074whom are you quoting?
>>54451791see>>54451768>>54450015
>>54451791A lot of people don't like their simple and sometimes retarded lyrics. A lot of hate comes fromvdeath grips fans
>>54449698underfaded roast
would meme grips be as popular without fantano's backing?
>>54451791A) Fantano likes themB) >but the lyrics are sooo dumbThat's all it boils down to
I love DG and Kendrick, definitely don't think they are both 10s.TMS - 8/10TPAB- 7.5/10ButJD - 9.5/10GKMC - 10/10but hey thats just my opinion, man
>>54451894[fakespoiler]I listen to Death Metal; I don't give a shit about lyrics.[/fakespoiler]
Anthony is easily impressed. He's a pleb
>>54451961Post good lyrics plsbtw Radiohead isn't going to work on people who are over 18
>>54451896>I love DG and Kendrick
>>54452044quality post friend
>>54449642>hiding titswhat a faggot
>>54449694>TMS a 8.5That's like a 5.8, also you're right about the Glenn Branca stuff, but i'm highly surprise of your standards, you seem to like good experimental music but in the other hand you caught yourself listening that tryhard shit
>>54451621Good one, Anthony.
>>54449642The Money Store - 7.5/10To Be Kind - 9/10To Pimp A Butterfly - 9.5/10
TMS 7.5/10TBK 7/10TPAB 9/10
>TBK9/10>TMS8/10>TPABidgafaboutthatniggershit/10
>>54451768LAST CALL FOR ALCOHOL
>>54449676yup.
>>54449936No I just really like that album.>>54449962Well I See Seaweed is the first Drones album I've listened to so maybe you're right.
>>54450015>>54453506Honestly, you know. I get it sounds kind of silly, and it's definitely one of the weaker songs on the album, but I still kind of like Tonight.Sorry.
You guys do realize it's just his opinion right?
>>54453506TURN UP THE LIGHTS IN HERE BAY BAH
I'd say more like a very strong 9 at most for any of those, but I don't object to the 10 ratings entirely.
i dislike his shallow and simply descriptive style of reviewing, but these album are all great and i think he has very good taste. I don't usually feel the need to assign a score to an album in my head but both TBK and TMS are at least 9s and TPAB is at least an 8
>>54453506MR ROCKEFELLER
>>54449642I really don't think Kendrick OR TMS deserve a 10 tbh, at least I wouldn't consider them 10's. And this is coming from a Death Grips fan. A 10 to me is something that resonates with you, whatever. TMS is just OK, and I don't see why any conventional hip hop album like TPAB would deserve a 10. Hip Hop is good for what it is, but you typically wouldn't call a comedy film "artistic perfection" and that's p much how I feel about hip hop. Idk
>>54449683Fucking shig
>>544496831970!!! HOLY SHIT!! Shouldn't you be dead already