[ cgl / con / g / mu / qa / w ] [ index / top / reports / FAQ / DAAS / IG / status / transparency / fuuka ] [ img-search ]
As Dark As My Soul Default Fuuka

/mu/ - Music (Temp full images)


View post   

File: 107 KB, 522x579, 1422799603011.jpg [Show reposts] Image reverse search: [iqdb] [google]
54126625 No.54126625 [Reply] [Original]

>Jimi Hendrix was not the greatest guitarist of all time

>> No.54126911

Greatest rock guitarist, maybe
Greatest guitarist goes to Robbie Basho

>> No.54127192

>>54126911
>Robbie Basho
literally who?

>> No.54127221

>>54127192
jesus christ leave
Adrian Belew is better, though.

>> No.54127237

>>54126911
Who what now?

>> No.54127250

I mean, Hendrix is pretty good man.

>> No.54127259

>greatest x of all time
Stop doing this.

>> No.54127260

>>54126911
Not even the best with the first name Robbie

>> No.54127264

>>54126911
>Greatest guitarist goes to Robbie Basho
nah is still jimi, you will understand someday

>> No.54127283

>>54126911
John Fahey >> Basho

>> No.54127286

Jimi Hendrix was one of the greatest icons of the 1960s. His death in 1970 still stands as one of the crucial events in the history of rock music. His work may be less important, as too many of his albums were below average. Hendrix was, after all, one of the most exploited artists of all times (many more albums were released after his death than during his lifetime). Hendrix made only two amazing albums: the first and the third, Are You Experienced (1967) and Electric Ladyland (1968). His greatest achievement was to coin a new guitar style, a style that amounted to a declaration of war against western harmony. Born at the crossroad between Chicago's blues, Memphis soul and Charlie Christian's jazz improvisation, Hendrix's style was an excruciating torture of tonal music. A black man, Hendrix always used the blues as the basis for his improvisation, but then used the whole human body to play and distort the sound of the guitar. The guitar became a sacrificial total for an entire generation. A cosmic hymn such as Third Stone From The Sun was fueled towards higher dimensions by the heroic guitar workout. The blues agony of jams such as Voodoo Chile was pushed to new psychological levels by the endless guitar pyrotechnics. Tracks such as 1983 borrowed from free-jazz and avantgarde music to achieve a form of "sound painting". On the album Band Of Gypsys (1970) Hendrix was indulging in endless acrobatics. Hendrix's guitar opened new doors to experimental music. His lesson would be applied not only to guitar but also to keyboards and to whatever instrument would lead a rock song.
Hendrix's case as a guitarist is unique in the history of modern music: Hendrix leads the "polls" of critics worldwide, even among jazz critics. Such a unanimity does not exist for singers or drummers or keyboardists.
His legacy as a guitarist is comparable to Beethoven's legacy as a symphonist.

>> No.54127312

>>54126625
but he got no.1 on rolling stones list

>> No.54127348

>>54127192
>>54127237
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-lFzu74gtQo
Educate yourselves

>>54127283
Acceptable opinion
They were both geniuses, but while Fahey gets the credit for essentially being the first of his kind, Basho's style feels more refined to me
But again, I'm not disputing Fahey's genius at all

>> No.54127384

>>54127348
hendrix is better

>> No.54127403

>Not the nigga from mahavishnu orc.
Not even fedora but theres no comparison as far as skill and personal sound.

>> No.54127425
File: 143 KB, 870x870, robert-fripp-1970-photo-willie-christie.jpg [Show reposts] Image reverse search: [iqdb] [google]
54127425

>not Fripp

>> No.54127459

The greatest guitarist of all time is Eddie Hazel. If you're gonna disagree, disagree with an alternative and a song better than maggot brain

>> No.54127465

>>54127348
Nah, Hendrix's crown is still on his bonce.

>> No.54127477

I know im going to get loads of hate for this, but Lucas Mann from Rings Of Saturn is insanely good. I don't know if Hendrix would be able to play what he does

>> No.54127487

>>54127459
Hendrix - Machine Gun

>> No.54127517
File: 1.39 MB, 320x180, 90e.gif [Show reposts] Image reverse search: [iqdb] [google]
54127517

>>54127477

>> No.54127525

>>54127477
it wasn't what hendrix was able to play but rather what and how he played. which is something practice can never get you.
plus he was a legit solid songwriter

>> No.54127575

>>54127487
>singing
it's good, but not even close to maggot brain

>> No.54127610

>>54127525
yeah, i get that. I know that Hendrix's songs had much more feeling and individuality behind them

>> No.54127674

>>54127477
>>54127525
>people still thinking technical ability has anything to do with talent

Talent is wholesomeness. The reason why Jimi Hendrix was and basically still continues to be the best rock guitarist of all time is because there was just more inside of his music.

>>54127459
Hazel was good but ultimately what was he? Just another Hendrix rip-off. The playing in Maggot Brain is good but it's just not fluid in the same way Jimi was.

What Jimi had that nobody else had or has is sensibility and abrasion, and a perfect combination of it such to make the abrasion sensible and the sensibility abrasive. An essential fluidity. Maggot Brain for instance really has a sort of dry sensibility at best.

>> No.54127681

>>54127575
Maggot Brain is an unfocused piece of shit. Eddie Hazel is just a poor Hendrix imitation.

>> No.54127726

>>54127348
>open tuning wanking

gross

>> No.54127759

Zappa is underrated as a guitarist

>> No.54127799

>>54127674
>Eddie's bad because he didnt play like hendrix
I don't think Hendrix could have done Maggot Brain like Hazel, what now? Hendrix would have looked like dry sensibility if he even attempted a song like maggot brain. Hazel is better

>> No.54127863
File: 17 KB, 500x282, Keiji watching the shitstorm.jpg [Show reposts] Image reverse search: [iqdb] [google]
54127863

>mfw this thread

>> No.54127934

>>54127759
he's in my top 5
his improvisation is god tier

>> No.54127948

>>54127799
Except what I said was that Hazel was bad because he did try to play like Hendrix, but that he failed in doing so.

>> No.54127975

>>54127948
But then played in his own style, and then fucking rocked.

>> No.54128009

>>54127975
lol nah

>> No.54128010
File: 206 KB, 904x944, Django_Reinhardt_(Gottlieb_07301).jpg [Show reposts] Image reverse search: [iqdb] [google]
54128010

Everyone ITT is wrong.
Posting the correct answer.

>> No.54128046
File: 67 KB, 300x898, 1421810929991.jpg [Show reposts] Image reverse search: [iqdb] [google]
54128046

>>54128009
>implying
lol Hendrix is a meme

>> No.54128055

>>54126911
Nah, Jimi is better than Basho and Fahey (who is better than Basho). They weren't as versatile or as groundbreaking imo. Fahey is still a top 3 guitarist, though (along with Django Reinhardt)

>> No.54128060
File: 40 KB, 600x400, frippy dippy doo.jpg [Show reposts] Image reverse search: [iqdb] [google]
54128060

>>54127425
Fripp wasn't even the best guitarist in King Crimson.
>inb4 muh NST

>> No.54128090
File: 13 KB, 300x300, 1414161531767.jpg [Show reposts] Image reverse search: [iqdb] [google]
54128090

>>54127681
fucking lol

>> No.54128105

>>54127403
Listen to McLaughlin's work before 1967 my friend. Jimi did jazz fusion better anyway

>> No.54128157
File: 475 KB, 836x714, mylets.png [Show reposts] Image reverse search: [iqdb] [google]
54128157

this guy might be the best guitarist right now

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=IM4iRzkZQLY

>> No.54128161

>>54127459
Hazel is the best of the Hendrix imitators for sure. Jimi is still better, and Hazel and every other guitarist would agree.

>> No.54128206

>>54128157
>singing over Reich minimalist guitar wankery
>best guitarist right now

A Y Y L M A O
Y
Y
L
M
A
O

>> No.54128255

>>54127863
Jimi's use of feedback and dissonance predates and outshine Keiji's, my friend

>> No.54128267

>>54128157
he'd be way better with a backing band.
also no.

>> No.54128293

>>54127674
>>54127681
Maggot Brain is all playing over the same basic scale.

Zappa is the only guitarist that comes anywhere close to Hendrix, and not just limited to guitar, either.

>>54127759
Mah nigga, he had one of Jimi's strats.

>> No.54128331

>>54128255
>predates
Yes
>outshines
No. Haino's guitar use has a much wider range than Hendrix mostly because he has been active for many more years.

>> No.54128350

Skydog.

>> No.54128409
File: 77 KB, 339x400, maha1.jpg [Show reposts] Image reverse search: [iqdb] [google]
54128409

All this guitarist talk, but no one mentions the GOAT. John Mclaughlin is the goat.

>> No.54128442

>>54128157
god dammit I hate it when kids try to be good it's like you're 19 you have literally 0 life experience other than imitation please just stop


but then again kids are kids but damn they just shit everywhere

also this culture systematically teaches kids not to be authentic

>> No.54128447
File: 131 KB, 500x616, 1415173048742.jpg [Show reposts] Image reverse search: [iqdb] [google]
54128447

>mfw /mu/ tries to have a music discussion

>> No.54128505

>>54128157
fuck this is pure cringe

>> No.54128659
File: 347 KB, 492x474, godyes.png [Show reposts] Image reverse search: [iqdb] [google]
54128659

>>54127425
>that guitar solo in Baby's On Fire

>> No.54128669

>>54128447
>im right
>your wrong and i dont care what u gotta say

>> No.54128699

>>54128442
>>54128505
he's decent, he just needs a band.
you guys are just sad fucks

>> No.54128735

>>54128699
>he's decent
this thread isn't about the most decent guitar players of all time

>> No.54128752

>>54128699
i think he's good. would not choose to listen to the music he makes in that video in a million years, but it's impressive still.

>> No.54128761

>cntrl+f "Pat Metheny"
>no results
Fuck off.

>> No.54128963

>>54127286
old copypasta is old

>> No.54129075

>>54128735
yea but the posts i quoted weren't debating that, they were just saying he's a kid fuck him for trying.

>> No.54129114

that's not how you spell J. Mascis

>> No.54129158

>>54129114
>J. Mascis
that's not how you spell asperger jr.

>> No.54129983

he wasn't

>> No.54130052

>>54128010
tru

>>
Name (leave empty)
Comment (leave empty)
Name
E-mail
Subject
Comment
Action