[ cgl / con / g / mu / qa / w ] [ index / top / reports / FAQ / DAAS / IG / status / transparency / fuuka ] [ img-search ]
As Dark As My Soul Default Fuuka

/mu/ - Music (Temp full images)


View post   

File: 95 KB, 259x194, Peart.png [Show reposts] Image reverse search: [iqdb] [google]
52840372 No.52840372 [Reply] [Original]

Name a better drummer
Protip: you actually can't

>> No.52840386

Bill Bruford

>> No.52840389

is that you're dad

>> No.52840391

John Otto

>> No.52840418

>>52840386
this.

>> No.52840445

Zach Hill
xD

>> No.52840527

>>52840445
xD

>> No.52840803

>>52840386
Pretty good
>>52840389
Kill yourself
>>52840391
Also pretty good
>>52840445
speed /=/ talent

>> No.52840834

Matt Gartska

>> No.52840835
File: 61 KB, 540x453, woodset.jpg [Show reposts] Image reverse search: [iqdb] [google]
52840835

Gavin Harrison or Danny Carey

>> No.52840861

>>52840372
go to sleep neil

>> No.52840877

Billy Rymer

>> No.52840900

>>52840386

Saw Bill do a solo show in LA like 15 years ago and it is still one of the most amazing displays of musicianship I have ever witnessed.

>> No.52840974

Terry Bozzio

>> No.52840992

DJ Shadow

>> No.52841022

>>52840861
I hate when he posts here trying to promote himself and his shortbuscore music.

>> No.52841043

ITT: PLEB OPINIONS

>> No.52841051

The guy from toe.

>> No.52841055

Stewart Copeland

>> No.52841079

Jaki Leibezeit is my favorite, also like zach hill off the top of my head

>> No.52841092

>>52840992
kek

>> No.52841114

Steve Gadd

>> No.52841146

>>52840803
lol chill out gramps

>> No.52841168
File: 127 KB, 600x855, Meg_White.jpg [Show reposts] Image reverse search: [iqdb] [google]
52841168

/thread.

>> No.52841187

dave grohl

>> No.52841198

>>52840372
Lee Harris

>> No.52841210

lars ulrich

>> No.52841216

>>52841168
this guy

>> No.52841251

the drummer from m1dy

>> No.52841264

Buddy Rich of course

>> No.52841297

Venetian Snares

>> No.52841303

>>52841187
kurt was a better drummer than dave

>> No.52841379

Eric Harland is better than whatever drummer you're thinking of.

>> No.52841437

time machine modulus guy

>> No.52841585

>>52840445
not wrong

>> No.52841795

Rufus Jones

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=LjJZJJ5QBhc

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=tPKYc0X76Gg

>> No.52841831

>>52840386
>>52841114
this and Phil Selway

>> No.52841848

Zach Hill

>> No.52841851

Buddy Rich you stupid nigger.

>> No.52841878

>>52841022
I kekd

>> No.52841892

Dave Wecklnh

>> No.52841901

>>52841168
She is so damn magical.

>> No.52841915

>>52841831
You ARE kidding, right? He does his job alright, but like listen to Pyramid Song, or the end of Reckoner. Simple shit and he can't even play it cleanly. He plays stuff that fits the music, which is good, but he's not a particularly good drummer.

>> No.52842026
File: 69 KB, 1920x1080, fuckthebugs.jpg [Show reposts] Image reverse search: [iqdb] [google]
52842026

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=TXpFrexDJ4A
get mad faggots

>> No.52842038

>>52842026
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=L4v8hOCeWfs
A better song for your earholes

>> No.52842060

>>52842026
yea he can play kinda fast... woo.....

>> No.52842076

>>52842060
listen to >>52842038
You also say that implying it doesn't take skill

>> No.52842081

Can someone for the life of me tell me why is work in Rush is so praised? I've listened to a bunch of Rush's stuff up until Moving Pictures, and Moving Pictures is the only album with remotely interesting drumming. I thought that was supposed to be the watered down mass appeal album.

>> No.52842099

>>52841187
>>52841303
Chad Channing is also better

>> No.52842117

Fucking 70's....

Not better than Peart, but better than a lot of drummers today
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=sdHyzGXAJPg

>> No.52842128

>>52842081
Bruh have you heard 2112? You're telling me rock drummers were playing like that at that time?

>> No.52842133

Jeremy Barnes
Alan Myers
Fenriz

>> No.52842162

>>52842117
is that mr sunshine on my goddamn shoulders john denver

>> No.52842175

>>52842162
Goddamn right.

>> No.52842186

>>52842128
Its the only other Rush album I sorta enjoy, but I don't think the drumming ever stood out to me. Bill Bruford's work on Fragile and Close To The Edge is far more attention grabbing.

>> No.52842187

>>52841168
Tits are amazing but do they bounce when she plays hmmm?

>> No.52842317
File: 68 KB, 550x413, matt.jpg [Show reposts] Image reverse search: [iqdb] [google]
52842317

Matt Halpern

>> No.52842420
File: 105 KB, 600x400, 13_justin_bieber.jpg [Show reposts] Image reverse search: [iqdb] [google]
52842420

>> No.52842491

>>52842076
yea its pretty hard when you first start out

>> No.52842538

>>52842420
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=WsPVagtIScU
jaden smith is better tho

>> No.52842633
File: 36 KB, 619x320, slint_1_1354190121.jpg [Show reposts] Image reverse search: [iqdb] [google]
52842633

the guy from slint

>> No.52842683

Neil is great but he has a tendency of over playing with too many fills. he's the epitome of quantity over quality.

>> No.52842708

Keith "the Loon" Moon

>> No.52842721
File: 24 KB, 330x266, ginger.jpg [Show reposts] Image reverse search: [iqdb] [google]
52842721

Pert is damn good

but picture related

>> No.52842760

Christian Vander, different style from Neil Peart, but more well-rounded as a musician and has a mad sense of creativity and dexterity on drums

>> No.52842786

>>52842721
lol he's p much a joke, it's incredible to me all the praise he gets.

>> No.52842999

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ouJetiHNAv0
Maybe not THE best, but Carl Palmer's definitely up there

>> No.52843891

>>52840372
Ginger Baker > cymbals mcfaggot tap

>> No.52843929

>>52842633
him, jerry fuchs and herb from primus

>> No.52843967

Vinnie Colaiuta

>> No.52843995
File: 152 KB, 958x784, 1420366111569.jpg [Show reposts] Image reverse search: [iqdb] [google]
52843995

>>52842786
>lol he's p much a joke
>Ginger Baker

>> No.52846114

>>52840372
Peart is a drum god, but I could easily put Tom Kirkpatrick or Mick Fleetwood beside him.

>> No.52846127

>>52842633
Britt Walford

>> No.52846133

Mango Starr

>> No.52846205
File: 74 KB, 800x1045, nmh.jpg [Show reposts] Image reverse search: [iqdb] [google]
52846205

>> No.52846218
File: 76 KB, 590x568, 1321648675928.jpg [Show reposts] Image reverse search: [iqdb] [google]
52846218

>drums
>requiring skill and/or talent

>> No.52846251
File: 19 KB, 544x489, 1315775845998.jpg [Show reposts] Image reverse search: [iqdb] [google]
52846251

>>52841168

>knock knock
>who's there?
>Meg White's drum skill

>> No.52846286

>>52841851
/thread

>> No.52846299
File: 25 KB, 630x473, elvin-jones-corbis-630-80.jpg [Show reposts] Image reverse search: [iqdb] [google]
52846299

hahaha nice one, OP

>> No.52846357

lars ulrich

>> No.52846838

>>52846357
>lars ulrich
Kill yourself

>> No.52846862

>>52846357

/Thread

Also Dave Lombardo

>> No.52846874
File: 195 KB, 630x420, Joey-Jordison.jpg [Show reposts] Image reverse search: [iqdb] [google]
52846874

>>52840372

>> No.52846893

>>52846357
It's a disgrace that much older guys like NP still demolish the skins while Lars drags himself around like he's 90 years old.

>> No.52846976

>>52840372
neil peart HYPE

>> No.52847004

>>52840445
yup

>> No.52847011

>>52840372
Today's tom soy gets on te through the friction of the day....
THE RIVVVVEEEEERRRRR

>> No.52847026

It's a funny thing how Rush have suddenly gotten relevant again since the late 2000s. I can't quite explain it.

>> No.52847029

>>52840372
that guy from Whiplash the movie
hes pretty dope

>> No.52847473

>>52841915
He's pretty good live. There's a clip of him going off when Radiohead plays Idioteque in Glastonbury back in 2004 or something

>> No.52847492
File: 42 KB, 610x351, sadwatson.jpg [Show reposts] Image reverse search: [iqdb] [google]
52847492

ctrl + f: bonham

Oh yeah, I'm in autistic faggot dream land, I forgot.

>> No.52847695

damon che

>> No.52848698

Terry Bozzio

>> No.52848719

>>52847695
This https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Ik0TnIwDbk4

>> No.52848728
File: 96 KB, 500x500, Panda+Bear+PS_animal_collective2.jpg [Show reposts] Image reverse search: [iqdb] [google]
52848728

>implying

>> No.52848761

Heard Mick Jagger can play the drums like a beast with his thick British cock.

>> No.52848832

>ctrl+f travis barker
>0 results

>> No.52848879

>>52842128
Tony Williams did it better in 1970, before 2112.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=fDjz9BzJ4cM
But you plebs wouldn't know what good drumming is like if it smacked you square in the face.

>> No.52848899

>>52842683
>over playing with too many fills
in other words
>I have no idea what I'm talking about

>> No.52848938

>>52842708
correct

>> No.52848953

>>52842420
>>52842538
Rivers Coumo

>> No.52849025

I doubt any of you are percussion students or decent drummers.
Therefore, your opinions don't matter

>> No.52849070

why don't any of you fucks know Chris "Daddy" Dave? Technique and creatively, bars above the rest. No one can touch the dude. Go get educated

>> No.52849105

>>52849025
Percussion performance major reporting in.
>>52849070
niggas don't know ablout h-town drummers because plebs everywhere.

>> No.52849115

>>52849025
that's exactly what i m seeing here.

>> No.52849143

>>52849105
why aren't you practicing?

>> No.52849171

>>52849143
because I just woke up.
practicing keiko and xenakis today.

>> No.52849202

>>52840372
Papa jo' jones
Jaki Liebezeit
Buddy Rich
Art Blakey

And remember kids, huge drumset=micropenis

>> No.52849220

>>52849202
>And remember kids, huge drumset=micropenis

Yeah, tell that to Ronald Bruner Jr, Thomas Pridgen, Chris Coleman, etc.

>> No.52849237

>>52840445

yeah

>> No.52849264

>>52841114
Yeah there you go

>> No.52849276

>>52840974
TERRY TED IS REALLY NEAT

>> No.52849296

>>52849220
I'm sure they all have small penises. Don't tell you actually believe that black cock shit. fucking faggot.

>> No.52849307

Dave Mattacks.

His set sounds absolutely stellar.

>> No.52849317

Sly Dunbar
Clyde Stubblefield
John French

some serious plebage ITT

>> No.52849341
File: 66 KB, 601x400, lightningbolt_061901_4.jpg [Show reposts] Image reverse search: [iqdb] [google]
52849341

Brian Chippendale

>> No.52849345

>>52849317
modern school of drumming wipes the floor with the drumming of a couple of decades ago.
the best today are influenced by the like of Clyde and them, but the best today are the best of all time, chops, time, musicality, experimentation, etc.

>> No.52849350

Bill Bruford, Mitch Mitchell, Brand X-era Phil Collins, drummer for VDGG whoever he is

>> No.52849355

>>52849345
no one sounds like Sly tho

>> No.52849364

>>52840372
>>52841187
>>52841210
>>52841297
>>52841303
>>52841831
>>52842081
>>52846357
:^)

>> No.52849397

>>52849355
and no one sounds like chris dave, eric harland, TP, RB, FW, Kendrick Scott, etc.

Also, not a single person has mentioned Calvin Rodgers. Fucking kill yourselves plebs.

>> No.52849416

>>52849341
lmfao
this guys has terrible technique
the only good thing about this dude is he plays real loud

>> No.52849418

>>52841251
I kek'd too hard at this.

>> No.52849421

>>52849397

hmm good choices actually

>> No.52849461

>>52849416
having good technique doesn't make you good.
I know a DMA percussion student who was brought up with fantastic technique, marched the Holy Name Cadets snare line for a couple of years in the mid 2000s when they started winning everything. He's a god awful musician/percussionist compared to a lot of the talent in the studio.
BC plays some really difficult passages in his music and it fits the aesthetic perfectly. I dare you to listen to his work and emulate his playing, see how you stack up compared to his "Shit" technique. he's a great drummer.

>> No.52849468

>ctrl+f "John Wright"
>no results
I know he's like 90 /mu/ but come on step it up

>> No.52849484

>>52849461
can you post an example of a passage, m8? everytime I listen to Lightning Bolt, I fall asleep

>> No.52849499

>>52849484
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=yVDhuFMMa9k

>> No.52849546

>>52849317
>>52849341
>>52841264
>>52842708
all better

>>52847026
It's because of all the edgy libertarian teenagers

>> No.52849556

>>52848728
This. Listen to STGSTV and tell me I'm wrong.

>> No.52849569

Jaki Liebezeit
Joey Baron
Vinnie Colaiuta
Matthias Bossi

>> No.52849580

>>52840445
le ebin meme

>> No.52849584

>>52840445
i guess you put xD in there because you never heard anything from him beside Death Grips

go educate yourself pleb

>> No.52849612

>>52840372
Peter Pleb and the Spotifies

>> No.52849617

It's a different kind of skill, but the drummers from the Melvins play in unison. The parts aren't super complex but it still takes a good bit of precision to match a partner's playing exactly.

>> No.52849619

>>52847695
the best answer

>> No.52849642

Roland from Big Black

>> No.52849726
File: 28 KB, 403x537, zach.jpg [Show reposts] Image reverse search: [iqdb] [google]
52849726

ZH

>> No.52849739

>>52849584
His stuff with Hella is even less tasteful.

All fills no substance. It's literally the drum equivalent of mindless guitar shredding.

>> No.52849759

>>52849739
>I don't know what a fill is but watch me use the word anyway to justify my shit taste and little knowledge of drumming
kill yourself.

>> No.52849763

Danny Carey
Joey Jordison

>> No.52849774

>>52849739
Are you stupid?
Zach can play in 20 different time signatures in a 5 min song. Orchestrated madness.

>> No.52849777

>>52849739
do you even mathrock?

>> No.52849803

>>52840372
Not quite my tempo

>> No.52849811

>>52849759
Are you implying this couldn't be just one long extended fill?

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-plG6mmyI_I

Zach Hill is shit and you have horrible taste in drummers. End of story.

>> No.52849813
File: 28 KB, 442x330, SSM_Laugh.jpg [Show reposts] Image reverse search: [iqdb] [google]
52849813

>>52849739

>> No.52849836

>>52849811
nigga doesn't understand what Mic Barr is doing either. come on kid!

>> No.52849844

>>52849811
i still hope you're baiting

>> No.52849859

>>52849811
Again.
>I don't know what a fill is or means but watch me use it to justify my shit taste and little knowledge of drumming

Shit taste as dubbed by you? a retard? do you think I care about what you think about my taste? kek
you have a lot to learn about drums kid.

>> No.52849872

>>52849836
He's jerking off aimlessly. You're retarded if you think there is any degree of composition or direction in this.

It's worse than fucking Yngwie Malmsteen as far as wanking goes.

>> No.52849896

>>52849844
>>52849859
Death Grips fans people.

Funny how you can't defend what Zach Hill is doing in these videos as anything else other than mindless wank.

>> No.52849924

>>52849896
>everyone liking Zach Hill must be Deathgrips fan too!

oh you poor pretenious autist

>> No.52849937

>>52849896
>I have no understanding of the concept of self expression through drumming
>drums must only keep time, not have its own voice within the mix of instruments

Kill yourself.

>> No.52849985

>>52849872
You're retarded if you think music is supposed to be played verbatim.
If you think like this, it screams non-musician.

>> No.52850000

>>52849937
hahahahahahahahahahaa

>> No.52850006

>>52849924
I agree with this guy. I bet that retard is completely unaware of Hill's solo projects

>> No.52850012

>>52849171
>keiko
Thumbs up, I'm way fucking jelly of your ambition. What piece

>> No.52850014

>>52849985
I love improvisation but this has no musicianship at all. It's literally just hitting as many notes as you can as fast as you can with no regards to structure,harmony,melody etc.

Complete fucking shit and wankery of the lowest kind.

>> No.52850032

Vinnie Colaiota (fuck his name)
Buddy Rich
Terry Bozzio
Ginger Baker

>> No.52850039

>>52849937
>>52849924
Death grips fans people

Funny how you still can't explain how this bullshit is good drumming except with. MUH EXPRESSION.

>> No.52850060

>>52840372
Bonham
Faggot

>> No.52850065

>>52840372
Britt Walford

>> No.52850123

>>52850012
variations on a japanese children's song
also a bach invention.

>>52850014
it's an aesthetic, much like free jazz, much like avant-compositions, much like industrial, much like metal.
Just because you don't like the aesthetic doesn't mean it's devoid of musicianship and complexity.
The physical stamina is impressive, let alone the speed within the context of the song.
The beauty about a duet is being able to do whatever the fuck you want. There's no exception in hella.
It's obvious he's highlighting certain harmonic motion, openings and closing of a phrase, embellishment of riffs, etc. It's all right there in that video, it just seems you can't wrap your head around it, and a lot of people can't, so I don't blame you for being so dumbfounded, but you're wrong.

>>52850039
>Music isn't expression
Kill yourself.

>> No.52850163

>>52840834
>>52840877
>>52841114
>>52841264
>>52841892
>>52842317
>>52843967
these

>> No.52850186

>>52850123
>The physical stamina is impressive, let alone the speed within the context of the song.

Again pure wankery, there's nothing musical about appraoching your improvisation as a physical endurance contest.

>It's obvious he's highlighting certain harmonic motion, openings and closing of a phrase, embellishment of riffs,

lmao, care to elaborate on what that harmonic motion is? Oh lawd don't tell me you're actually impressed that they can match accents every now and then.

>Music isn't expression

Sure it is an this is an expression on par with taking a shit on the sidewalk.

>> No.52850223

>>52848728
Nice b8 faggot

>> No.52850311

>>52850186
Drumming is a physical activity. In order to make music drumming, you need to be physically able to drum. To separate physicality and musicality in drumming is stupid and something someone who doesn't know what they're talking about would say, i.e. you.

harmonic motion is the motion of the harmony in a piece of music. harmony is the underlying tonal/chordal structure a song is based on, but not necessarily "chord progressions".

it's much more than "matching accents every now and then"

You're obviously sour about something, maybe your life lacks ambition. maybe you're just a sad cunt who can't cut it in music and think flinging stupid strings of words on the internet gives you some self-worth. Whatever the case may be, you're annoying and act like a teenager. Grow up.

>> No.52850371

>>52850311
I know what harmony is you dumb fuck. I want you to explain to me the harmonic structure in that piece and what Zach Hill is doing to highlight it (your words) What else besides occasionally matching accents is he doing to make any type of reference to the guitar playing.

>grow up

That's rich coming from the guy telling people to kill themselves because they can't handle Death Grips.

>> No.52851137
File: 599 KB, 480x270, neil peart.gif [Show reposts] Image reverse search: [iqdb] [google]
52851137

omg there is no fucking drummer better than neil peart

>> No.52851201
File: 180 KB, 600x400, Helm.gif [Show reposts] Image reverse search: [iqdb] [google]
52851201

This guy

>> No.52851836
File: 77 KB, 525x356, billyandmickey.jpg [Show reposts] Image reverse search: [iqdb] [google]
52851836

>> No.52851898

who yall been listening to?

i've been studying a bit of elvin jones shit, i love him god damn

he rips on a love supreme throughout

>> No.52852158
File: 2 KB, 121x125, heh.jpg [Show reposts] Image reverse search: [iqdb] [google]
52852158

>>52842026
>peppered cancer

>> No.52852286

>>52850039
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Iq1omYjyQqM
Tell me that the drumming in this song is just wankery. Zach Hill is a very talented drummer just for some reason he prefers the spectacle of shready masturbatory drumming, and in all honesty I enjoy watching him do it because it is intense and fun, but you can't say he isn't a talented drummer beyond being able to play fast.

>> No.52852473
File: 89 KB, 593x397, ginger_baker.jpg [Show reposts] Image reverse search: [iqdb] [google]
52852473

>>52840372

Kinda hard to beat the guy who literally invented rock drumming by combining jazz and african styles...

>>
Name (leave empty)
Comment (leave empty)
Name
E-mail
Subject
Comment
Action