[ cgl / con / g / mu / qa / w ] [ index / top / reports / FAQ / DAAS / IG / status / transparency / fuuka ] [ img-search ]
As Dark As My Soul Default Fuuka

/mu/ - Music (Temp full images)


View post   

File: 28 KB, 715x463, kanye-west-paul-mccartney-only-one-mp3-main.jpg [Show reposts] Image reverse search: [iqdb] [google]
52591362 No.52591362 [Reply] [Original]

Thoughts?

>> No.52591380

Can't even listen to the full song
Fuck autotune

>> No.52591400

Liked the lyrics and instrumental. Autotune felt a bit tacky. 6.5/10

>> No.52591583

Pretty good, the people getting upset about it are keeping me entertained

>> No.52591584

>>52591362
Terrible, but then again I'm not a fan of West.

>> No.52591626

>>52591583
>pretending to like shitty music cause it pisses mommy and daddy off

litttrrly 13 year old

>> No.52591665

>>52591362
>genric
>bland
>idk even know when mccartney plays
>lyrics
>important
why you just dont listen to Justin Bieber or some shit?

>> No.52591719

>>52591362
Would be a great tune if it weren't for the autotune. It worked on yeezus and other releases but come on ye, the gimmick is over. Waste of a song.

>> No.52591751

Lyrics were ok at best
Instrumentation was poor
The autotune just sounded like it was parodying him, way way off.

>> No.52591786

>>52591362
Love that picture of them though

>> No.52591805

I'm not even gonna listen to that nigger crap

>> No.52591855

Incredible

>> No.52591869

Sounds sloppy

The auto tune is horrendous. Not sure what he's trying to achieve with that. John Cale used it a lot on his last album too.

>> No.52591873

>>52591805
Thanks for entering the thread and sharing your opinion mate.

Have a nice day

>> No.52591892

>>52591362

>2015

>Autotune

2/10

>> No.52591894

No need to believe this is interesting just because his other music is. How masochistic you people are.

>> No.52591899

amazing

>> No.52591908

boring

>> No.52591915

>>52591362

Stale garbage

>> No.52591949

At this point, some people will praise anything he releases no matter how bad it might be. This track for example. It's a shoulder shrugger.

>> No.52591971

Ligit, the worst song I've heard in my life.

>> No.52592018

>>52591362
nothing special

>> No.52592032

I think it's beautiful and one of his most personal songs and a lot of people can connect to it on an emotional level without being involved in the events in the song. Paul McCartney plays the keyboard and does background vocals. Kanye has obviously been influenced by people like James Blake or just straight up soul music and the song also has a modern take than his early work. He's developing himself as a musician. It's like a stripped down version of 808s.

>> No.52592065

i don't intend to hear it. i don't like either of them that much, and especially don't like the idea of them publicity stunting together. shit's aggravating.

>> No.52592068

>>52592032
good thing he's developing himself 15 years into his career

l
m
a
o

>> No.52592148

>>52592032
James blake! That's who i was reminded of. A really, really poor man's james blake who doesn't understand the intricacies of the man he's emulating.

>> No.52592295

>>52592032
Backing vocals is actually ty dolla $ign

>> No.52592380

Trash/10

>> No.52592591

I think its bretty good. Nothing complicated, just a fine pop tune.

>> No.52592639

>>52592591
one sampled loop repeated through the whole song, terrible lyrics, horrible production. Worse auto tune. We are past that, it's 2015. This is legit the worst song I've ever heard in my life. We need to get past this.

>> No.52592665
File: 169 KB, 1920x1080, fish sticks.jpg [Show reposts] Image reverse search: [iqdb] [google]
52592665

I'm thinking Ebony and Ivory

>> No.52592670

>>52592639
woah, you must have like - no heart

>> No.52592672

>>52591362
Meh

>> No.52593254

>>52591894
are you serious? none of his music is particularly interesting, unless you're in middle school

>> No.52594115

>>52591362
1/10

how can he go from yeezy to this

>> No.52594685

>>52592148
>implying Kanye didn't birth James Blaks's career

>> No.52594962

>>52594685
I really don't think he did

I like the song

>> No.52595042

>>52591873
>le totally mad but pretending not to be face

>> No.52595420
File: 84 KB, 600x857, shrugs.jpg [Show reposts] Image reverse search: [iqdb] [google]
52595420

I thought going into it that Paul's vocals would be on it. Like, he'd sing the hook or - God forbid - rap a verse. I spent the whole song waiting for him to come in and make me cringe, and then only afterwards found out that he just played piano.

Whatevs.

>> No.52595827
File: 116 KB, 1280x638, tumblr_lyvvisGzMw1qmsk3bo1_1280.jpg [Show reposts] Image reverse search: [iqdb] [google]
52595827

>>52594962
James posted this on his blog a few years back

>> No.52596243

>>52595827
goddamn james blake has shit tier taste, who knew

>> No.52596267

>>52595420
>rap a verse
that would be godly. damn anon, now i'm hoping paul has a verse on the album

>> No.52596281

if he kills himself i knew it

>tell nori bout me
>laying on the stage

>> No.52596302

>>52596281
if kanye was ever kill it would be the single greatest day on mu other then all of death grips and every sing k pop slut dying of aids.

>> No.52596592

>>52591362
Kanye has always been a favorite of mine because of his devotion to his personal feelings.
They usually come out brash and without concentration (see any outburst or Yeezus for example.)
That's interesting enough just because of how extreme and dramatic he is.
I'm very feeling-oriented and pretty sensitive, so I'm usually more tolerant towards his outbursts and confusion.
As someone who's balanced the struggle with verbally articulating my feelings through my art, I connect with what he often fails to communicate outside of his music.

However, when he creates interesting perspectives for us to view the circumstances surrounding his feelings and outbursts, I can start to appreciate him less as a person and more as an artist. Pieces like "Blood on the Leaves" are what make him a great artist in my opinion.

This song is subtly built on soul with a guide that knows the ins and outs of good song structure.
However, Kanye's melody and improvisation are the key feature here even above a knighted Beatle.

After his mother's death, several break ups and falling outs, and now yet another massive shift in the inevitably ugly Kim divorce, it's hard for me to hear this song and not empathize with his position. A child is really what he needs to keep his faith and sanity at this point. And I'm glad he finds a feeling of sanction, especially through his deceased mother.

I hope this song's approach to musicality and Ye's emotional musings foreshadow the upcoming LP's rumored soul vibe he was once known for, but not because "old Kanye is best Kanye".
As a person it's the direction he needs to hold to; hopefully this is the promise of more heartfelt art from our favorite hothead.

>> No.52596620

>>52595042
I'll speak for him when I say that nobody gives a shit

>> No.52596637

>>52591380
>>52591400
>>52591719
>>52591869
>>52591892

Holy what the fucking 2008 youtube comments, kill yourselves.

>> No.52596669

>>52592068
>implying kanye developing is happening just now
>college dropout to LR
>LR to Graduation
>Graduation to 808's
>MBDTF to Yeezus
it's like you're actually deaf if you can't acknowledge the advancements he's made between each record.
They're big, often polarizing even his biggest stans

>> No.52596670

A predictable lame gimmick.

>> No.52596687

>>52592148
It's Paul at the keys, homes..

>> No.52596738

no

>> No.52596742

>>52596670
No gimmick here, son.
It's literally the exact opposite as it's fuckin stripped down to McCartney on Rhodes and Kanye with autotune, which is his signature anyways. That's it. No flashy gimmick.
It's just a song. Is presenting a stripped down song actually considered a gimmick to you?
Jesus, this thread.
/mu/ is no longer valid for any kind of intelligent discussion as you fucks can't even evaluate anything for yourselves without spouting buzzwords..

>> No.52596805

>>52596666

>> No.52596984

>>52596742
fuck off to reddit then

>> No.52597344

>>52596637
Le right generation!

>> No.52597400

>>52596742
dont expect to have any intelligent discussion about any /mu/core artists.

>> No.52597758

if you don't like this you aren't high enough

>> No.52599342

who is paul mcartney?

>> No.52599352

>>52599342
He was in the band "Wings"

>> No.52599386

Amazing song. One of the best of the 21st century so far.

>> No.52599408

Tell Nori about me

>> No.52599813

>>52595827
What's the album next to unknown pleasures?

>> No.52599881

>>52599813
the one with the in-progress fornication is Washed Out - Within and Without

idk to the left

>> No.52599893

>>52591805
Absolutely underrated

>> No.52599907

>>52599813
>>52599881
one of the left is Bon Iver, Bon Iver by Bon Iver

>> No.52599915

>>52599352
>not "Paul McCartney & Wings"

>> No.52599938

>>52599342
Wasn't he the dude that made that one electronic song? Temporary Secretary?

>> No.52599948

i liked it

>> No.52599955
File: 51 KB, 1248x620, cmonfantano.jpg [Show reposts] Image reverse search: [iqdb] [google]
52599955

it sucks cunt

>> No.52599957
File: 50 KB, 715x463, 1420344066170.jpg [Show reposts] Image reverse search: [iqdb] [google]
52599957

>> No.52600151

>tfw Paul will never do something like this again
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=zdTs-iLBKME

>> No.52601900

>>52596637
autotune is like 2008 stuff, get over it... it sounds like shit

>> No.52601921

>>52599999

>>
Name (leave empty)
Comment (leave empty)
Name
E-mail
Subject
Comment
Action