[ cgl / con / g / mu / qa / w ] [ index / top / reports / FAQ / DAAS / IG / status / transparency / fuuka ] [ img-search ]
As Dark As My Soul Default Fuuka

/mu/ - Music (Temp full images)


View post   

File: 16 KB, 271x236, lou-reed-sized.jpg [Show reposts] Image reverse search: [iqdb] [google]
48826770 No.48826770 [Reply] [Original]

10) Gary Numan

9) Iggy Pop

8) Daniel Johnston

7) Dave Grohl

6) Syd Barrett

5) John Lennon

4) Kanye West

3) Robert Fripp

2) John Cale

1) Lou Reed

>> No.48826786

>>48826770
>>48826770
>>48826770
>>48826770
>>48826770
ebin meme dude

>> No.48826798

glad to see fripp climbing the talentless hack ranks he's been an underrated hack for too long

>> No.48826801

HEY

gary numan is p. good

>> No.48826863

Mods need to ban this stuff.

We need intelligent democratic discussion....BY FORCE.

>> No.48826893

>>48826863
>intelligent democratic discussion
Like that's gonna happen faggot.

>> No.48826901

>>48826770
he's not pointing at us, damn...

>> No.48826923

>>48826801

It is not about good or bad. Talentless hacks can also make great music like Lou Reed's Berlin but at the end of the day they are talentless hacks.

>> No.48826943

>>48826770
What do you have against Fripp?

>> No.48826961

>>48826943

I personally have nothing against him. Lou Reed, John Cale, Iggy are all my favorite artists but I made the list considering the consensus of /mu/

>> No.48827009

>>48826770
What about Nick Cave ? :^)

>> No.48827108

1: Conor Oberst

Honorary mention: Henry Rollins

>> No.48827435

Essential talentless hack-core? How do I become a talentless hack? How about a talented hack? Or a hacker?

>> No.48827460

Honorary mention of Jim Morrison.

>> No.48827601

>>48827009

He is great.

>> No.48827623

eeeeeh, im not into this list. I dont feel comfortable calling any of those guys talentless hacks, even if im not a lou reed or kanye fan

>> No.48827639

>Syd Barrett
wut

>> No.48827643

>>48826770
Fripp? That's just silly

>> No.48827662

>>48826770
What is your opinion on Jeff Buckly? Or Daniel Johnston? imo they're two of the greatest artist in Modern Music...

>> No.48827671

>>48827601
It is not about good or bad. Talentless hacks can also make great music like Nick Cave's The Boatman's Call but at the end of the day they are talentless hacks.

>> No.48827714

>>48827671
kek

>> No.48827759

>>48827671
>Nick Cave
>Talentless

Huh...

>> No.48827800

>>48827759
It's a joke m8, read the thread. everyone loves Nick Cave.

>> No.48827890

>>48827800

Bollocks, he's not talented. He's been reliant of Roland, then Mick/Blixa, then Ellis.

>> No.48827899
File: 75 KB, 600x411, b4dd69fd-6234-4a53-a861-2aae8354f.jpg [Show reposts] Image reverse search: [iqdb] [google]
48827899

>>48827800
This. Hard to hate such a fair pal

>> No.48827919

>>48827108
>conor oberst

id like to see your lyrics

>> No.48827920
File: 52 KB, 600x411, 7ca2e1d2-1de7-4967-abcd-cdc88e228.jpg [Show reposts] Image reverse search: [iqdb] [google]
48827920

>>48827890
>Roland
>Mick/Blixa
>Ellis
Tbh this is pretty true but you can't deny that he writes lyrics all by himself and they're great as fuck

>CAPTCHA: oursux serve

>> No.48827931

>>48826770

>tfw only really offended by Kanye on this list

It is good to be born in le right generation

>> No.48827944

what is the point of these stupid ass bait troll threads. fucking garbage

>> No.48827947

>>48826893
>>48826863
intelligent discussion died when people started liking ebin maymays more than patricians

>> No.48827950

>>48827920

Whilst I haven't read The Death... yet I think, based on And the Ass Saw the Angel, that I'd prefer him as a writer of novels more than songs.

>> No.48827952

>>48827890
>nick cave
>not talented
You're embarrassing yourself.

>> No.48827991
File: 92 KB, 604x403, c4a16e95-a857-4136-bf32-5e9ecc4ce.jpg [Show reposts] Image reverse search: [iqdb] [google]
48827991

>>48827950
haven't read either, I should though

>> No.48828003

>>48826770
I'm fine with this

>> No.48828011

fairly accurate

>> No.48828018

The Boys Next Door
1979 : Door, Door

The Birthday Party
1980 : The Birthday Party
1981 : Prayers on Fire
1982 : Junkyard

Nick Cave and the Bad Seeds
1984 : From Her to Eternity
1985 : The Firstborn Is Dead
1986 : Kicking Against the Pricks
1986 : Your Funeral... My Trial
1988 : Tender Prey
1990 : The Good Son
1992 : Henry's Dream
1994 : Let Love In
1996 : Murder Ballads
1997 : The Boatman's Call
2001 : No More Shall We Part
2003 : Nocturama
2004 : Abattoir Blues/The Lyre of Orpheus
2008 : Dig, Lazarus, Dig!!!
2013 : Push the Sky Away

Grinderman
2007 : Grinderman
2010 : Grinderman 2

>> No.48828069
File: 55 KB, 600x400, eee9b074-4e0c-4b63-bd06-b1748f02b.jpg [Show reposts] Image reverse search: [iqdb] [google]
48828069

>>48828018
Nocturama is his worst work ever, no wonder Blixa left. He even said to Nick at the filming of 20,000 days... That it was so different that he was in tears

>> No.48828094

>>48828069
35 years of music. One bad album.

>> No.48828128
File: 1.21 MB, 1920x1080, 55259e36-becc-4f95-a0f8-e3f517576.png [Show reposts] Image reverse search: [iqdb] [google]
48828128

>>48828094
Yes and it's a fucking good achievement

>> No.48828157

>>48827639
That's what I'M saying.

>>48826770
Fuck you OP!
Your a talentless fag.

>> No.48828198

I miss Lou Reed

>> No.48828226

>>48828018

I still stand by the claim that The Peel Sessions anthology is probably the best Birthday Party release. That These Immortal Souls cover is divine.

Your list also doesn't include some of his amazing side work: Die Haut, Nick Cave & the Cavemen, Dirty Three (Live at Meltdown for example), his soundtrack work with Ellis to name but a few.

Out of all of those the only one that I wouldn't choose to listen to is probably Nocturama.

>> No.48828238

>>48826770
>Iggy Pop

I will fucking murder you. How can you be so retarded not to see how important The Stooges albums were. Punk wouldn't of existed without those albums and Metal would be unrecognizable.

>> No.48828249

>>48828128
Indeed.

>>48828226
Yup, this is a wiki ctrlV-ctrlC. His soundtrack work is hugely overlooked.

>> No.48828275
File: 228 KB, 500x750, 1406738227577.jpg [Show reposts] Image reverse search: [iqdb] [google]
48828275

>>48828238
>wouldn't of

>> No.48828291

how did kanye make this list you idiot?

>> No.48828307

>>48828238
>Metal would be unrecognizable

I like Iggy but that's a bit overboard. Blue Cheer had already put out Vincebus Eruptum about a year prior to The Stooges putting out an album.

>> No.48828319

>>48828291

By making sample music and claiming he is a god.

>> No.48828398

Kanye is the only one that deserves to be on this list.

>> No.48828399

>>48828307
I still think Metal would of existed without the stooges, I just think it would have evolved differently than it did. A lot differently

>> No.48828426

>>48828275
*have

I know it's wrong but it's one of those mistakes I make time and time again, I guess because I say would've a lot.

>> No.48828524

>>48826770
>Gary Numan
Stopped reading there

>> No.48828632

wayne coyne is a talentless hack

>> No.48829098

>>48826770
Everything about this list is wrong. Also calling people talentless hacks is stupid. If they can make music that appeal to at least 1 person then they have talent.

>> No.48831052

>>48829098

No. Talent > Appeal.

>> No.48831076

>Syd Barrett
>Talentless hack
I think you mean Roger Waters

>>
Name (leave empty)
Comment (leave empty)
Name
E-mail
Subject
Comment
Action