ITT: 9+/10 post-punk albumsPic related
But that album is shit, OP.
>>48646227agree completelyposting the obvious
The superior post-rock album coming through!
>>486462278/10>>486462498.5/10>>4864625110/10>>486462649/10
>>48646227Anything here, especially Magazine and Killing Joke
>>48646306This is the best shit ever
>>48646227>>48646251>>48646287>>48646306>>48646330ok>>48646264>>48646249dross>>48646267very fucking dross
>>48646267>post-rock
AN ORDER IS AN ORDEREVEN WHEN IT MAKES NO SENSE
>>48646342>LOOK AT ME GUYS I HAVE SHIT OPINIONS
>>486462279/10>>486462496/10>>486462646/10>>486462878/10>>486463308/10
>>48646342Why do people dislike Marquee Moon and RIL so much? Is it because they're /mu/core?
>>48646362SNOWWWWWWWGIRLLLLLLL I MELT YOUUUUUUU
>>48646362WE ARE WE ARE WE ARE WE ARE TIIIIIIIIIIME
>>48646401not even the best clash album
>>48646389there's been some weird anti-new wave backlash lately. I dunno
>>48646351That was an embarrassing brainfart, yeah...
>>48646405If you mean anything but s/t you are completely wrong
>>48646362WHAT DOES IT FEEL LIKETO KILL A MAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAN
>>48646410Marquee Moon isn't new wave and XTC who are new wave have been getting a lot of love.
>>48646369Lol. Typical petulant Chameleons fan.
>TFW no one posts the best one.
>>48646427>XTC who are new wave have been getting a lot of love.True. I don't think I've seen a single person say anything negative about XTC on this site.>Marquee Moon isn't new waveDamn, is it not? Sometimes I have a hard time keeping track of post-punk genre boundaries
Better than Script of the Bridge.
>>48646430>Lol. Typical contrarian shitposter
>>48646227>>48646249>>48646264>>48646267>>48646401GOD NO>>48646251>>48646306>>48646435Choice cuts>>48646287>>48646330Ehhh
>>48646435>>48646329
>>48646455Marquee Moon is considered Art Punk>>486464356/10
>>48646455Yeah New Wave is a lot more poppier.
>>48646483Art Punk is such a bullshit genre though. It's too similar to traditional post-punk to be considered it's own genre.
>>48646483>6/10Go home, Grim Fantano.
>>48646525Fandango LOVES Wire, he gave Pink Flag 10/10
>>48646511I think it is overall more punky than post-punk and doesn't stylistically diverge much from punk. Post-punk is much more different. For example, when you listen to Pere Ubu you can easily see something is different. Art punk feels like punk with influences.>>48646525Huh?
>>48646465>liking Hex Enduction Hour, Y, The Modern Dance, Jane From Occupied Europe and Deceit>contrarianYour posts positively scream "clueless meme-ridden 14 year old ". lol
>>48646525Fantano loves Wire though, he gave Pink Flag a 10/10.
>>48646547>For example, when you listen to Pere Ubu you can easily see something is different.It sounds just as punk as Television to me.
Obviously, as is /mu/'s custom, this is an inflated ratings thread, however I'm surprised to say that every album posted thus far (at least with images attached are at least a 7.5, most are even an 8). Of course, they are also all entry-level as fuck so it's not like anyone on this board hasn't heard them.
>>48646570Television is between punk and post-punk, so you can tag it with both genres
>>48646573>this is an inflated ratings threadHow? I think that everyone here has posted his own 9/10 post-punk album here. Not all of us agree with everything here. For instance, in my opinion, the only 9/10 post-punk album is >>48646227
>>48646573~~~THIS THREAD HAS BEEN BLESSED BY THE TRUE PATRICIAN~~~JUMP INTO THREE THREADS AND POST ABOUT HOW YOU'RE FAR ABOVE THE DISCUSSION TAKING PLACE~~~AND GOOD LUCK WILL COME IN THE NEXT WEEK!
Is No Wave allowed here?
>>48646573you have no idea how much you're impressing me
>>48646620No Wave is definitely a Post-Punk subgenre, so sure
>>48646647not a subgenrebut post punk had influnce on it
The Pop Group and This Heat are the pinnacle of Post PunkWire is punkTalking Heads is new wavePiL is good too
>>48646573>Fedora tipping intensifies.
>>48646663but who has as many good albums as the Fall?
>>48646573Because obscure post-punk is sooo much better, right? As the "entry level" noise group Gerogerigegege once said: GO GET FUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUCKED
>>48646689The Fall has no good albums, anon.
Is this Post-Post-Punk?
>>48646704ayy fuck face-uh
>>48646620>>48646647>post two of the least interesting no wave albums everlol, /mu/.
>>48646704Epic.
>>48646573>Berates everyones tastes and favorites.>Doesn't post any examples of his patrician post-punk records.;^)
>>48646711branca's rock n roll
>>48646689The Fall's a weird oneThey have so many albums that to me are 7/10, 8/10But none of them reach the heights of the 9/10s achieved by This heat and Pop Group
>>48646711No Wave is post-punk so yes.>>48646704"HEY THERE FUCKFACE" - Mark
>>48646711No, it's straight up classical.
>>48646743This Heat only have a single 9 out of 10LOL THE POP GROUP
>>48646744What a story, Mark!
>>48646767What do you have against the Pop Group?
>>48646744Calling the ascension post punk would be pushing it.Also, no wave is hardly a genre.
>>48646767To me both This Heat and Deceit are 9/10Pop Group is easily my favorite post-punk group.
>>48646755It's classical, post-rock and no wave at the same time.
>>48646796Both classical and post rock are such vague genres anyway, so why not.
>>48646767Pop Group is literally the only post-punk group to have a 9/10 recordeducate yourself>>48646781No Wave is a genre, why not?
>>48646849No wave was more of a scene or an umbrella term than a genre.
>>48646884You could say that Krautrock is like that as well, scenes can also be genres.Also, calling No Wave an umbrella term is dumb.
>>48646910Krautrock is not a genre, bro.
>all this Fall lovemy obligatory niggas
>>48646936But it is. Krautrock was a scene, and it's a genre exactly because it was a scene.
>>48646968Educate yourself.
>>48647039That one sucks.
>>48647039I haven't seen The Slits posted in so long.
>>48647095first track is good rest is a sleeping pill
>>48646342I like how some people have to act edgy and deny that RiL and Marquee Moon are great albums, because they want to seem like a special snowflake that doesn't agree with a pretty much accepted opinion. >>48646573You could post what albums you think are worthy, or you could just sit there and complain about everyone else and contribute nothing too, that's productive...
>>48647039Really bland pseudo Punk and mediocre Post Punk. I'm not surprised one of them is Lilly Allen's aunt.
>>48647174Is that post-punk, though?
>>48647164Not the guy you're replying to but I have seriously never like Remain in Light. I think it has two good tracks and the rest are tripe mulling over the same sound without doing anything interesting with it.
>>48647173Which post-punk albums do you enjoy?
this is a 9/10 for me
>>48647202I don't particularly think Post Punk is all that great to be honest, but Marquee Moon was a good album.
What relation does post-punk have to actual punk rock?
>>48647216It's shit.
>>48647244it's punk rock with an artsier edge basically
>>48647238It's strange how /mu/ has started to hate Marquee Moon. I still think it's great. I think Art Punk is a bit of a pretentious label though.
>>48647244post-punk was the result of people who had cut their teeth on punk rock developing wider musical ambitions
>>48647244It's like punk but /mu/ would consider it more fedoraish.
>>48647275/mu/ hates it? Since when? It's a great album and was very innovative.
>>48647305Nah but I've seen people start to dislike it more. Kinda like what's happening with The Smiths and Sonic Youth. It doesn't mean everyone hates the album though.
>>48647333People hate Sonic Youth now? The Smiths I can understand.
>>48647382Yeah some people are starting to be more open about hating them but mostly Daydream Nation.
test post please ignorealso>the chameleons>good
>>48647253>>48647283>>48647302But does it sound at all like punk? Granted I mostly prefer hardcore so my perception may be flawed.
>>48647333To be honest I never saw the hype around Sonic Youth (I listened to Dirty, Goo, Confusion Is Sex, Daydream Nation, EVOL, Sister) or The Smiths, I can see that they were quite influencial but I find the music itself isn't that great, however, outrightly hating them for the sake of hating them is a bit much.
>>48647429why ask? people have posted a shit load of albums in this thread already. just pick one and see for yourself.
>>48647438listen to sonic youth's s/t and bad moon rising for their no wave era
>>48647174I love The Replacements with all my heart, but they are most definitely not Post-Punk.
>>48647438Yeah I had trouble getting into SY as well but I think Daydream Nation and Sister are 6.8/10s. I enjoy The Smiths a lot though.
>>48647469I appreciate the recommendations but quite frankly I've listened to enough Sonic Youth, in a few years time I'll retry but for now I've had my share.
>>48647429post-hardcore is more similar to hardcorepost-punk is somewhat more abstract
>>48647408Go fuck yourself, olly.
>>48647473they were a punk band and developed a pop edge with Let It Be. does that count as post-punk or do they have to be art-y too?don't honestly know at this point
>>48647608They're closer to alt rock.
>>48647616i thought alt rock grew out of post-punk / punk?
>>48647648Alternative rock is basically the post-punk of the 90s.
>>48647656but alt rock was primarily an 80s movement
>>48647608>they were a punk band and developed a pop edge But... that's New Wave, isn't it?
>>48647722No no no you've got it all wrong. Post-punk with a pop edge is new wave. Genres are so damn confusing sometimes.
>>48646660yesalso
>>48647751So... this album is new wave?
>>48647800Uh... Ye-... no...
>>48647722
>>48647800look lets say weve got punk. an artsier and more quirky form of punk is post-punk. now have no wave on the left, and new wave on the right. no wave is more abrasive, less accesible, anti-pop, while new wave is more pop-oriented and commercial form of post-punk. no wave and new wave don't come from post-punk, they're just by its sides. gothic rock comes off post-punk and alternative rock or indie rock comes off post-punk as well
>>48647761This looks interesting, never heard of it, listening now.
>>48647829Not even the best 80s Cave album.
>>48647829
Where the fuck is Killing Joke
Signals, Calls and Marches too (even though its an EP)
>>48648097because killing joke is too gawff
>>48646227
it helps that the bassist and guitarist from the pop group were both in this band
very much on the industrial side though
>>48648268Mayb if ur an idiot
>>48648441do u kno what is goth rock? im sorry that u get pissed bc u dont know genres
>>48646264>television>post punk
>>48648838read wiki
Unknown Pleasures is better than every album posted ITT.
>>48648300This and Glitterhouse are both fucking sweethttp://www.youtube.com/watch?v=cOS8iTC5hzk
>>48648951>read wikiYou don't want anyone to take to seriously, do you?Television is art punk. End of story.
>>48646249For the last time this is new wave
>>48649952You know that albums aren't limited to one genre, right? Remain in Light is primarily New Wave, but there's also elements of Post-Punk, Funk, and Experimental Rock.
>>48646660Yes yes yes.But from the lions mouth is even better
Anyone ever listen to The Proletariat?
>pic related9.3/10>Destroyer - Streethawk: A Seduction9.0/10>John Coltrane - My Favorite Things9.8/10>Jens Lekman - Night Falls Over Kortedala9.2/10
>>48651840>coltrane>post-punkalthough i agree with the rating
>>48646287the only correct answer so far ITT.>>48646711i would agree with this but the problem is is that it's not post-punk.>No Wave, Noise Rock, Experimental Rock, Post-Minimalism (according to RYM)
Ratings are horseshit. This isn't discussion. You simple ass children.
That album is proof that not all experimentation is good.
>>48652422Y? That album is one of the rare examples of experimentation done right.
>>48652175Holy shit I didn't even notice the "post punk" part of the OP. My bad.
>>48652443I find that "Deceit" and "Y" are very good for being so damn experimental and dissonant.
>>48654668Those two albums do experimentation completely differently, but they both turn out to be wonderful
>>48654689Yeah, definitely.I particularly enjoy how "Deceit" ends up coming across as a solid concept album about the Cold War with the recurring themes of political unrest and collapse/nuclear weapons.Plus the more "commercially viable" tracks like "SPQR" and "A New Kind Of Water" are stellar."Y" is hard to accurately describe, but I rather enjoy it.
>>48655670post punk?
>>48646726>>48646711>>48646647>>48646620Yes
>>48655777you hyped for new doomsday student?
>>48655803Pretty excite yes : )
>>48655873new songs sounded great too. they just announced their west coast tour as well but unfortunately too far for me
>>48648268feg>>48648097lol thats not whats this for
>>48655929Ugh bummer, yeah I live on the east coast. Their Trans Peco live set sounds good.