[ cgl / con / g / mu / qa / w ] [ index / top / reports / FAQ / DAAS / IG / status / transparency / fuuka ] [ img-search ]
As Dark As My Soul Default Fuuka

/mu/ - Music (Temp full images)


View post   

File: 24 KB, 534x443, 1389738957592.jpg [Show reposts] Image reverse search: [iqdb] [google]
43415377 No.43415377 [Reply] [Original]

What instrument do you play /mu/?

>> No.43415395

qwerty keyboard

>> No.43415401

base geetar

>> No.43415423

>>43415377

Vocals are my main "instrument" (>hurr durr not an instrument). Next best is clarinet, and I also play the piano.

Recently started learning bass for fun because I was bored whilst home from uni and my dad has a few lying around

>> No.43415425

Hell yeah bitch. What up? I play the fucking bass, piano, cello, saxaphone, guitar, cello, violin, mandola.

>> No.43415436

violin and muh guitar
what about OP

>> No.43415467

>>43415425
jelly

>> No.43415486

>>43415377
clarinet

>> No.43415504

bass guitar, the computer, voice

>> No.43415506

geetah
drooms
peeno

>> No.43415507

the synthesizer

>> No.43415510

>>43415436
I just bought a bass guitar, thinking about getting a Glockenspiel in the future, i'm trying to sell my violin because i didn't got into it as much as i wanted, also it's extremely hard

>> No.43415516

>>43415377
Sax, flute, bleep bloops, piano, guitar, bass, drums, and clarinet. I also sing in tune but I'm not too find of my voice and I don't got range.

>> No.43415522

Piano, guitar, trumpet and vocals.

>> No.43415524

ableton

>> No.43415528

>>43415425
and you suck with all of them.

>> No.43415538

Bass (guitar), Guitar and I've just started trumpet.

>> No.43415545

theremin

>> No.43415547

guitar bass synths

>> No.43415567

Geetar, Bess, Drems
Geeter being my main instrument. Looking to becomer a teacher of the geetar later on in life

>> No.43415589

Drums. Nobody on this board is better than me.

>> No.43415593

Bass, bass guitar, piano, computer.

>> No.43415610

>>43415528
I play all the instruments in the entire world.

>> No.43415615

Guitar
Bass
Drums
Violin
Viola
Piano

>> No.43415641

trumpet, piano, guitar, bass

>> No.43415645

Saxophone and Bass Clarinet

>> No.43415939

>>43415615
Proof?

>> No.43415969

didgeridoo

>> No.43415987

>>43415939
>take music theory
>Understand how chords progressions are made
>Understand Scales
>Understand what a tone and semi tone is
>apply to strings
>Write music

>> No.43416002

>>43415377

the lute

come at me faggots

>> No.43416013

Xylophone, marimba, etc.

>> No.43416028

>>43415377
Guitar, electric and acoustic
Keys

>> No.43416064

>>43416002
>playing the lute
>thinks thats not cool.

>> No.43416072

>>43416013
Cool, wanted to ask you something, i'm thinking about buying a Glockenspiel, are there any recommended brands?

>> No.43416086

>>43416064

dude i think its awesome, no one tells me what to do.

>> No.43416129

>>43416072
Not him, but Yamaha is usually the go-to brand for the professional.

>> No.43416150
File: 25 KB, 350x400, 1389740719723.jpg [Show reposts] Image reverse search: [iqdb] [google]
43416150

>>43416086

>> No.43416179

cello (extremely well)
piano (adequately)
guitar (extremely poorly)

>> No.43416201

>>43415377
Been playing the drums for 4 years (not doing lessons anymore)
and I fiddle with the guitar

>> No.43416203

>>43415510
oh and i forgot, i can beatbox really good.

>> No.43416234
File: 58 KB, 754x817, 1389740919956.jpg [Show reposts] Image reverse search: [iqdb] [google]
43416234

Guitar only. I've always wanted to get good at piano but I just never put in the time.

>> No.43416247

Weird fucking Chinese shit I play.

>> No.43416283

Soprano flute
Piccolo flute
faite me

>> No.43416296

Guitar
Bass
Piano/Synth/Keyboard
Trombone

What I'd like to learn in the future:
Theremin
Trumpet

>> No.43416309

Piano
Viola
Cello
Cor anglais
French horn
Trombone
Vibraphone
Harp
Glass harmonica
Bonang
Steelpan
Koto
Sitar

>> No.43416351

french horn.

got a $40,000 scholarship for it.

too bad i hate it and i'm being forced to major in music to get the money. i'm miserable and want to drop out.

>> No.43416366

I play the guitar, improvising with the aid of scales over autogenerated rocksmith backing tracks for meditational purposes. It works.

>> No.43416430

>>43415377
guitar. I also sing

>> No.43416519

>>43416351
Think of new radical ways how to use your french horn. GET TOGETHER WITH OTHER HORNETS AND PLAY FRENCH HORN PROTEST SONGS ON THE STREETS OF YOUR CAPITAL

>> No.43416606

>>43415423
god people calling voice an instrument is annoying. why can't people just say they sing when asked what instrument they play. it doesn't sound nearly as retarded.

/end autism

>> No.43416624

saxophone, guitar

>> No.43416636
File: 34 KB, 300x300, 1389741607027.jpg [Show reposts] Image reverse search: [iqdb] [google]
43416636

>>43416351
Bass Trombonist here, similar issue, except I'm waaay more interested in acoustics and a ton of other shit than playing the damn horn, but stuck with a performance because the school is shit with want I want to do. Not to mention 4 zero credit music courses.

Otherwise, in order of ability
-Trombone (bass/tenor)
-Tuba/Trumpet (I can play these about the same)
-Violin
-String Bass

also sing Baritone in the opera, only because there's required vocal performance and the choir sounds like dying cats.

>> No.43416645

>>43416351
Play your horn like Beefheart did on Trout Mask Replica
Then do the same thing, but better, as a soloist for a free jazz band.
Then, enjoy the eternal praise.

>> No.43416648

>>43415939
who the fuck asks for proof on /mu/. is this your first day? god damn this thread is getting my rage up.

>> No.43416654

>>43416636
what school?

>> No.43416682

>>43416351

Start a free jazz group with your french horn. Become a world renowned jazz player.

>> No.43416689
File: 439 KB, 500x500, 1389741702988.png [Show reposts] Image reverse search: [iqdb] [google]
43416689

FL Studio

>> No.43416842
File: 52 KB, 554x527, 1389742004164.jpg [Show reposts] Image reverse search: [iqdb] [google]
43416842

>>43416654
Won't say because I'd get doxxed immediately.

For anyone looking to go to school for music, be extremely careful. Even if it's cheap/you get scholarships. If you do go, don't start with it immediately, you'll be in too deep soon enough, to where you'll be able to transfer if it starts to look like a shitfest.

>> No.43416991

>>43415987
this. I dont get why people refuse to learn theory

>> No.43416992

>>43416645
>>43416682
>and thus, /mu/tants started all kind of free jazz bands with horns,trombones, flutes, cello and whatnot
>this new wave of free jazz is soon called mucore
>mucore becomes /mu/core

>> No.43417020

>>43416991
but didn't you know it makes you LOSE ALL YOUR CREATIVITY AND WRITE INSIDE A BOX CREATED BY SOME OLD DUDES HUNDREDS OF YEARS AGO or some shit

>> No.43417048

>>43416992

That would be GOAT. Be right back, I'm going to go buy a euphonium, book some studio time, and start my jazz career. See you bitches after I'm on the cover of Wire.

>> No.43417116

>>43417048
>See you bitches after I'm on the cover of Wire.
#shotsfired
>>43416842
>tfw have been putting off finishing my final piece for my composition application for two months

>> No.43417127

>>43417048
Where you from m8? I'm >>43416283 and I'd actually like to give it a try but
>tfw no one arround me takes that project seriously and even wants to give it a try

>> No.43417129

drums and tabla, used to play french horn

>> No.43417159

>>43416648
Kill yourself

>> No.43417200

guitar, drums, bass (obvs anyone that can play guitar can play bass), piano, trying to into mandolin for some serious folk shit haha

>> No.43417248

>>43417127

I live in Austin, Texas currently. I've played piano for a good 14 years, with private lessons the entire time. I took lessons for the cello as well but practice that on my own now. I also manage to find my way around on the guitar, though just barely. Same with the violin. I actually played french horn for like 3 years, but I never liked it that much. I just thought I should try a brass instrument. I'm not in school for music or anything, though. I would really love to start any kind of jazz band, although I'm not sure how able I would be considering I've never played any jazz pieces.

>> No.43417306

Needs more drummers.

>> No.43417314

Flute, harmonica, kazoo, and I'm learning drums.

I'm awful at drums.

>> No.43417323

>>43417248
Well shit, we're not even in the same continent.

>> No.43417327

I play Drums, Bass, 7 string guitar, and Tuba

>> No.43417328

>>43415401
>>43415423
>>43415425
>>43415504
>>43415510
>>43415516
>>43415538
>>43415567
>>43415593
>>43415615
>>43415641
>>43416296
>>43417200
How good are y'all at bass?

>> No.43417338

>>43417323

Fuck, man.

>> No.43417342

>>43417020
its only that way if you let be that way. I use music theory to help build an understanding of music. Not to make better music. If something sounds nice to me, whether or not if follows music theory's, It sounds good.

>> No.43417382

>>43417328
This is >>43415593

Got half of a performance degree, have played for 11 years now. I've sort of quit playing now though.

>> No.43417388

>>43417328
decent, I'm pretty bad at slapping though (it doesn't fit my playstyle anyway)
I've been playing bass for 7 years

>> No.43417414

>>43417328
I played in a ska band for awhile, I took a lot of inspiration from Streetlight Manifesto's bassist/played a lot of Streetlight covers. To you it might not be much at all, but I was proud of what I wrote/performed.

>> No.43417452

Guitar, alto sax, clarinet, recorder, mandolin, trumpet, sitar (cheap 3/4 size with several broken strings I'm too lazy to replace), oud (ornamental but I strung it with nylon guitar strings and it makes a surprisingly good sound). I also have a keyboard, an electric organ, a violin and a flute but I can't really play any of them.

I mostly play for my own amusement, my compositions are all written for computer rendering rather than human performance. I do plan on creating some pieces with computers and live instruments eventually, but at the moment I'm just not ready to devote myself to working out the logistics of such an arrangement.

>> No.43417499

Classical violin bitches. #2classy4u

>> No.43417510

>>43417328
like, wooten-good.

>> No.43417528

geetah

>> No.43417552

>>43417499

Are you good?

>> No.43417592

guitar and dulcimer

>> No.43417641

>>43417552
Pretty good, I'm working on Introduction and Rondo Capricciosso by Saint-Saens now. I did the Mendelssohn Concerto earlier

>> No.43417649

>>43415377
Guitar

Learning piano, I really need to practice more. In fact I'm about to get off /mu/ and practice some right now
also learning vocals

>> No.43417700

>>43417342
that wasn't serious you know

>> No.43417734

>>43417020
I use music theory to write down and understand what my mind came up with intuitively. All the music I make kind of follows music theory, so it's in no way a box for me.
Also it's easy enough to forget all the 'rules' for a moment and hit some random frets.

>>43417328
>>43415504 here. I would say okay, learned a couple of years on my own, followed lessons for a couple of years. I'm at a point right now that I don't really feel that I need to get a lot better.
I can't play super fast technical stuff but I don't really want to either. I know way my way around and I can improvise and jam.

>> No.43417772

>>43417700
>>43417734
I know it wasn't serious but I'm going to spread around my opinion anyway.

>> No.43417774

I was in a marching band from the age 4-14 playing the drums, then I got a proper drumkit when I was 15.

I'm 19 now and I mostly play the Cajón with a heck-stick (because i'm too poor to upgrade my drumkit....also because the cajón is fucking gr8).

I also play the harmonica and am currently saving up for a trumpet.

Any recommendations on what trumpet to buy? I was thinking of starting with this one: http://www.thomann.de/ie/thomann_tr4bbtrompete.htm but only because it's cheap and I have no clue about trumpets.

>> No.43417784

How do I money for piano lessons?

How badly do I need piano lessons? I have a box full of sheet music from beginner to intermediate cause my mom used to teach piano, so I was thinking I could just plow through that sheet music and it would be no different than taking lessons, right?
Basically what would I miss from teaching myself at first instead of lessons?

>> No.43417795

Are you computer people DAW scrubs or do you actually know what you're doing?

>> No.43417823

>>43417795
I use Ableton and a little bit of SuperCollider. I know my way around Ableton and use it live.
SuperCollider is really fun but not that useful for my music.

>> No.43417860

>>43417784
You would mostly lose a lot of time if you teach yourself how to play, especially if you want to use partitions.

>> No.43417879

>>43417823
>SuperCollider is really fun but not that useful for my music.
How? You can do pretty much anything with it.

>> No.43417920

Mandolin, didgeridoo, various weirdo homemade folk things, piano, and synths.
I've owned a guitar since high school but I've never gotten very far with it. I know some chords.

>> No.43417922

>>43417860
Explain, what are partitions used for?

also in which ways would I lose time

>> No.43417931

>>43416309
>tfw no one responded to my blatant lies

>> No.43417948

Been playing violin since I was four. Drums are my main instrument currently but I also sing play synth and play bass.

>> No.43418013

>>43417931
because /mu/ are so talented we didn't second guess it, of course

>> No.43418024

What's the best way to make myself dedicated/put my nose to the grindstone?

I really have a passion for music, but so often I can never practice for more than an hour or two without getting distracted and listening to music or watching videos on the internet or what-have-you

How do I increase my want to practice? what practice techniques do you guys use?

>> No.43418048

>>43417922
Well you are the one who said you have a box full of music sheet, so I suppose you do know what partitions are for.
And you lose time because when you are teaching yourself how to do something,you need to find out how to do thingss yourself. It may take a lot of time to see or understand something that can be simply explained by someone else.
Also one of the good aspects of having a teacher is that he can se your progress and change your tutoring accordingly.

>> No.43418076

>>43417784
>needing piano lessons
in all honestly. paying money to learn is unnecessary and also down right lazy.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6gHEIF0rT2w

watch this guys videos on music theory and practice what he says. Much easier, cheaper, effective than instructor

>> No.43418088

>>43418048
I thought partitions are walls? also it's my mothers sheet music

>> No.43418091

>>43418024
>take breaks often
>set defined goals
>get comfy

>> No.43418093

>>43418024
watch tutorials on youtube so you can follow along with them

>> No.43418106

>>43418024
Practice every day for 30 minutes instead of trying to do a 2 hour session every week.

>> No.43418116

guitar and bandolin

>> No.43418125

>>43418024
Turn off your computer and leave the room.

>> No.43418197

>>43418091
>set defined goals
I think this is my major flaw, my practice has no structure a lot of the time
Will try to do

>>43418106
That's far too little time I think, I usually practice at least an hour a day, I want to increase it to a high amount
I hear stories about really talented pianists who practice upwards of ~6 hours a day, that's the kind of goal I want to reach, I'm wondering how that sort of thing is even possible

>>43418125
Will do

>> No.43418210
File: 1020 KB, 400x229, 1389744761894.gif [Show reposts] Image reverse search: [iqdb] [google]
43418210

>>43418076
>paying money to learn is unnecessary and also down right lazy

>> No.43418229

>>43418197
>I hear stories about really talented pianists who practice upwards of ~6 hours a day, that's the kind of goal I want to reach, I'm wondering how that sort of thing is even possible
It's possible by taking a lot of breaks, seriously, that's the secret.

>> No.43418235

>>43418024
practice learning how to cover songs you like. That way, you are listening to music and practicing at the same time. Over time, you will just grow a natural habit or practicing and continuously grow your skills, wanting to play more difficult and challenging pieces. You should also learn some Pentatonic scales and understand how to chords are created, the difference between a major and minor scale, and tone degrees. In time you will end up growing a habit for practice for hours

>> No.43418258

>>43417774
any other cajonfags in this thread?

>> No.43418259

>>43418024

Practice for an hour a day. Do stretches, then warm-ups (like finger exercises), scales arpeggios and chords, then finish by working on songs/styles you've been wanting to learn, playing them slowly and cleanly and building up speed.

Consistent practice is better than long practice. At least one hour every day.

>> No.43418292

>>43418210
Just saying.
Never had an instructor, never paid for lessons. Just taught myself music theory, practice song I liked and over time got better. I just don't see the purpose of paying for something when I just do it myself for free.

>> No.43418305

>>43417795
I use Cubase.

>> No.43418317

>>43418116

apparently in english its written mandolin for some fucked up reason

>> No.43418333

>>43418197
don'teven believe you can work for 6 hours in a day as of right now. You physically can't until you are alredy quite used to your instruments. And "quite used to your instrument" does not mean that you have been playing it for a few months, but a few years. And those who work for so long don't actually work that much on actual pieces of music. 50 to 75% f the work is routine and technical exercises.

>> No.43418387

>>43418292
>Never had an instructor
Then how do you know you're as good as you would be if you did have one?
PROTIP: you aren't. Everyone who's self-taught has delusions that tutors are useless and they're far better off without them. Such a totally ridiculous idea but even I believed it at one point.

>> No.43418421

Trombonist here. Getting a new horn this month, it'll be pretty great
starting college next year, still undecided about majoring in music

>> No.43418430

Guitar, bass, mandolin, and some banjo. I like bowing guitar and banjo. Working right now on a 4 string acoustic guitar. I'm adding something to lift the 2nd and 5th strings so they can be bowed easier.

>> No.43418435

bass geeter
steelpan
basically every percussion instrument because high school.

>> No.43418487

>>43418229
>>43418235
>>43418259
thank you all for the advice

So I'm going to set up a mental schedule of some sort now, recommend any changes you think I should make

-30 minutes to 1 hour of "play" time, just time to dick around and get it all out of my system. then a stretch break and some finger exercises
-1 hour scales, arpeggio's, and applying (at least) one theory lesson, another break possibly a long break
-2 hours sight reading and going over previously learned pieces. break in the middle and at the end
-30 minutes to 1 hour "play" time again later in the day before sleep

What do you think? obviously I'm going to deviate from the schedule some days, but this is a general outline to make sure I cover all my bases

>> No.43418517

>>43418333
What sort of technical exercises should I be doing? is there any online resources you can link me that contain some of them?

>> No.43418518

>>43415610

So you don't even space bass? Pleb

>> No.43418538

>>43418487
Honestly dude, break it into 45 minute segments. That's what I used to do when I practiced ~9 hours a day, and what all the people I know that put in tons of time do.

>> No.43418555

>>43418487
that's way too much, see >>43418333
You can't go from working 1 houer a day to four hours a day. If ou do so, all you will do is hurt yourself to a more or less serious degree depending on your instrument.

>> No.43418580

>>43415377
Banjo, guitar, bass guitar, and synthesizer. I've played others before, but I won't claim to "play" them.

>> No.43418590

>>43418538
I see, so I should do shorter segments but make them more frequent
thanks

>> No.43418617

>>43418590
Also, do less things.

I'd dedicate each session wholly to that one thing I'd decided to do (exempting warm-up).

>> No.43418635

>>43418555
So I should casually ramp it up over the course of time or what? I can easily do two hours a day now without problem

>> No.43418675
File: 9 KB, 188x268, 1389745705226.jpg [Show reposts] Image reverse search: [iqdb] [google]
43418675

I sing and play guitar. Once I get semi decent with a guitar I intend on learning piano next, and just maybe drums.

>> No.43418679

I was a percussion major for a few years (marimba, vibes, xylophone, concert snare, drumset, latin percussion, Turkish hand drums, etc.) but I switched majors.
I can play basic acoustic rhythm guitar and very poor bass guitar and piano.
My musical strength is in the theory rather than the instruments.

>> No.43418682

drums
bleep bloops
bass guitar

>> No.43418689

>>43418617
So you're saying I should do different things depending on the days of the week? Like, sight reading on tuesday/thursday, other shit on monday/wednesday or whatever? and then split it all up during the day?

thank you all for responding by the way this is immensely helpful. I want to establish good practice habits now while I'm a beginner

>> No.43418703

guitar, piano, synths and drums

>> No.43418724

>>43418635
Don't go brutally from 2 hours to 5 hours. set yourself one date,in a few months, and gradually go from nearly 2 hours now to 5 hours at the decided date.

>> No.43418760

>>43418724
Ok, I see, thanks for the advice man

>> No.43418802

>>43418387
can say the same exact thing about you watch,

>had an instructor
Then how do you know you're as musically insightful as you would be if you didn't have one?
PROTIP: you aren't. Everyone who has had a tutor hold their hand through their training of becoming a musician is prone to not having a sound of their own and keeps musicians away from being creative and innovative in the leaning process. Such a totally ridiculous idea but even I believed it at one point.

Instructors tell you to play this scale in this key in this tempo without any context or understanding of what it all means.

"Play an A chord", Why?, "Because I'm the instructor and I told you to". Well What is an A chord "is just this", Why do I put three fingers down, "its too complicated" well what does type of notes make up an A chord, "I'll tell you that later. Its too complicated".

Very insightful and though proving isn't it

>> No.43418830

>>43418802
I'm self-taught.

>> No.43418885

>>43418802
That's what happens when you take lessons as a kid, or have a shitty instructor. A good teacher should tell you why you may need to learn something. A good teacher understands your needs and can tell you why you learning a specific point may be benefic for you.

>> No.43418906
File: 591 KB, 1010x1347, 1389746105206.jpg [Show reposts] Image reverse search: [iqdb] [google]
43418906

Pretty much anything that makes a musical sound since I play stuff by ear but this is what I actually own.

>> No.43418953

>>43418906
>playing electric fan
I love you, anon.
I really do.
Please, marry me.

>> No.43418967

>>43418487
i agree with >>43418555. Don't practice for long periods of time until you are comfortable playing your instrument and until you are physically ready to sit down and focus. It would only seem like a chore and will put a strain on you. Think of if this way. Practice isn't a chore, or a something to put on your do to list. Practice is something that once you take part of, you end up saying I practice not I have to or because if I don't, I will be behind, I practice cause its fun

>> No.43419042

>>43418953
Yeah man, put some reverb on there and you're a shoegaze wizard right in your bedroom.

>> No.43419062

>>43418953
it's like a really cheap vocoder.

don't even tell me you didn't make darth vader voices when you were really young

>> No.43419139

Euphonium & trombone.

Taking a piano course next year.

>> No.43419178

Classically trained bass-baritone, so that takes up most of my time.

Also play the clarinet (and bass clarinet) and piano, can mess about on an organ but i'm not very good at that, the pedals throw me a bit.

Can play a bit of guitar and bass too.

>> No.43419248

guitar, acoustic is alright sometimes but i mainly like electric

I wish i had the balls to make being a guitarist my full time job

>> No.43419307

>>43418885
I taught myself because I was passionate enough about the music I listen to and play. I feel that when you a teacher in the picture, I takes way from the innovative, thought provoking, and insightful strive one has for music. Its seems that the music you are passionate in is forced. Yeah you may play faster than me and yeah you may learn about music at a much quicker pace than me. But in the end it's not about how fast we learn about music, its about how well you can take what you have learned about music and apply it to create something creative and beautiful. Its about how one can take what they have learned about music and envision something they can create and master and call their own. And when put a instructor in the picture. It doesn't feel like my own. It doesn't feel like I created this piece of art. Some guy taught me how to do this. This isn't a work of mine. Its just some result of another man's work created through me. Thats why I don't like instructors. Cause whatever I create or discover, or play, I all because of another person. Not because of my dedication and passion for it. Its because I paid a dude to tell how to do this.

>> No.43419368

>>43418885
its a feat to create music. Its a much greater feat to teach yourself to create music.

>> No.43419418

>>43419307
Except a teacher is not there to tell you how to play one piece or two (or at least, should not).
He is there to help you progress and learn how to use your instrument. The rest is up to you.

>> No.43419526

Guitard, vocals

>> No.43419527

>>43419418
It's not exclusive to learning pieces. When being taught by instructor, you are technically stating the "the foundations of my knowledge about music is not me, but a guy I paid to tell me"

like i said,
its a feat to create music. Its a much greater feat to teach yourself to create music.

>> No.43419590

>>43419307
this

>> No.43419685

>>43419527
Did you drop out of high school too? Perhaps you don't need textbooks, you can learn math yoruself

>> No.43419705

>>43419418
When you teach yourself something, you do not get any knowledge, only skill. Not that this is a bad thing. This is just different. You do not have the same understanding of what you are doing.
Plus, one of the positive aspects of having a teacher is that you have an external pointe of viewon what you do, someone who can help you see your own work under a different light.

>> No.43419756

>>43419685
>implying that everything we know about math is equally as easy to learn music.

can't compare apples to oranges my friend

>> No.43419799

>>43419756
Music is essentially math.

This is why you need a teacher.

>> No.43419820

>>43419685
>compares learning about objective truths to expressing yourself through art

0/10 fail troll

>> No.43419839

>>43419820
If you don't have a teacher, how do you know if you are playing something properly?

>> No.43419865

>>43419685
I think you just buried yourself.

>>43419705
There are no negatives to having a good instructor of course, but there are no negatives to learning things by yourself either unless you're trying to join a symphony orchestra and be first violin or something. It's not exactly necessary for someone who casually makes music in his or her spare time to know every technical detail about music.

>> No.43419866

>>43419799
theres so much more to math than there is to music. Like calculus, Geometry, Statistics to an extent etc.
Music is essentially addition subtraction at most.

>> No.43419897

>>43419820
>OK student, this is how you play an A chord
>NO DO NOT SUPPRESS MY ART!

>> No.43419944

>>43419839
>music can be played "properly"
hurr de durp
>>43419897
This.

>> No.43419982

>>43419944
>>music can be played "properly"
See >>43419897

>> No.43420039

>>43419897
Nobody said this anywhere you twat.

>> No.43420067

>>43419944
As a percussionist, I can vouch for the fact that improper technique can cause physical problems.
As far as the music you make, there isn't necessarily a "proper" way to do it, but I would make the case that you will acquire skill more quickly with a teacher (that doesn't suck).
I took a very basic class on playing acoustic guitar and essentially just learned all the major and minor chords (already had a bunch of theory knowledge), then just played a shitload to get better.

>> No.43420130

>>43420067
Totally agree
>>43419982
>trolling
not worth my time...

>> No.43420138

>>43420039
See >>43419307
>>43419527

>> No.43420161

>>43420067
Which improper techniques are you referring to?

>> No.43420178

>>43420130
So you are saying that any random notes can be an A chord? Because that's being creative?

>> No.43420201

guitar. gonna start messing with the keyboard too since my friend wants me to sign up with him for a piano class.

>> No.43420257

>>43420178
Once again, nobody anywhere said this.

>>43420138
There's nothing like that anywhere in either of those posts.

>> No.43420267

>>43420178
nop

>> No.43420309

>>43420257
Why did you run away from our argument in the Beach Boys thread?
>>43420267
How would you know without a teacher?

>> No.43420410

>>43420309
You don't have to know what chords are called

>> No.43420414

>>43420309
Got bored, figured you got the point that Brian Wilson's creative role in the Beach Boys was heavily diminished after Surf's Up, though they still had brilliant material after 1971.

>> No.43420443

>>43420414
>Got bored, figured you got the point that Brian Wilson's creative role in the Beach Boys was heavily diminished after Surf's Up,
That's not what you said though.

>> No.43420455

>>43420161
>>43420161
If you fuck up your 4-mallet grip, your stick grip, even your timpani strokes, you can cause wrist problems.
It's really easy to get fucked up playing afro-cuban music because when you play it, you play for hours at a time on one rhythm.
It's not necessarily likely, but I can't speak for other instrument families as I don't play them.
Plus, your technique has a big impact on your tone, the speed you can play, the ease of learning new pieces with difficult sections, shit like that.
There's a reason professionally trained musicians are commonly considered the best.

>> No.43420488

>>43420410
>Hey band member, play an A chord so we can jam
>NO I DON'T NEED TO KNOW WHAT THE CHORD IS CALLED STOP STIFLING MY CREATIVITY

>> No.43420520

>>43420410
Couldn't hurt. You can learn what chords are called by yourself though. That's the easiest stuff ever.

>>43420443
Pretty sure that's exactly what I said other than making an exception for Surf's Up. It is one of my favorite albums and I assumed you were aware that I knew Brian had a big role in it so I didn't really think it was necessary to directly make an exception for it.

>> No.43420543

>All these self taught shits thinking they can play their instruments at a grand level without having an instrutor at some point of their lives.

>> No.43420545

>>43420488
im pretty sure most musicians have eyes and ears

>> No.43420586

>>43420520
Oh yeah I know what chords are lol. It's just that you don't have to know in order to create music

>> No.43420653

>>43420586
>Hey bandmate play an Amaj7/G lets jam
>NO YOU DON"T HAVE TO KNOW THIS SHIT TO CREATE MUSIC

>> No.43420693

>>43420520
>Pretty sure that's exactly what I said other than making an exception for Surf's Up. It is one of my favorite albums and I assumed you were aware that I knew Brian had a big role in it so I didn't really think it was necessary to directly make an exception for it.
lol You are so full of shit.

>> No.43420704

piano, drums, guitar, bass, saxophone, didgeridoo

but I mostly use my drum machines and synths

>> No.43420728

>>43420653
>Amaj7/G
Why would you even want to do that though?

>> No.43420731

>>43420653
u dont

>> No.43420760

>>43420693
Believe whatever you want, bro.

>> No.43420801

>>43420760
Thanks for the tip

>> No.43420861

>>43420731
>YOU DON"T HAVE TO KNOW THIS SHIT TOI MAKE MUSIC
>yeah but I am another individual who would like to make music with you, so we need a common language to communicate our musical ideas. Didn't you have an instructor to teach you this, so that we are free to be create after learning this language?

>> No.43420999

>>43420801
Don't know what else to tell you, sorry.

>> No.43421025

>>43420999
Just admit you made a mistake.

>> No.43421033

>>43420861
nah man i didnt. cheers

also man learn to read music by ear, you suck man rofl im getting a new bandmate

>> No.43421210

>>43421033
Its more likely you are going to go work on your DAW and post on 4chan about how you can't find any bandmates.

>> No.43421286

>>43421025
About what? I was giving an answer to the question "did you stop listening to the Beach Boys after 1971?" which was a reply to someone saying everything Brian Wilson composes is gold (I agree). Surf's Up came out in 1971. I was saying Brian's role declined after that.

>> No.43421321

>>43421210
Actually, I'm in a band, fuck you!!

>> No.43421368

mandolin
harmonica
double bass

>> No.43421393

>>43418024
Vary it up. I'm an amateur drummer and pretty much here's my routine/ritual
>Hour of warm up and Stick Control
>Hour of rudimental solo work and using Syncopation
>Two hours of whatever I'm currently working on for kit out of books/lesson material
>As much time as I can playing along with music, learning a song, making up beats, or just improving to a met. Usually three to four hours

This is all broken up over the day, currently I'm trying to consolidate breaks in this a bit though because this schedule is only possible from me working part time and living at my Dad's. I'm hoping to go to school for drum set performance next Fall though.

>> No.43421394

>>43421286
You said Brian didn't write more than two songs after his breakdown. That is incorrect.
>>43421321
No you're not

>> No.43421541

>>43421394
Uhhh yes i am

>> No.43421593

>>43421394
I was exaggerating. I am completely aware of his input on most albums in the 70s, but it's extremely sparse compared to what he did in the 60s (everything).

>> No.43421600

>>43421541
How do you make music? Do you just play random notes?

How do you know how to play an A chord?

>> No.43421644

>>43421600
Hmm? Oh I know what chords are, and so do my bandmates, even if we only play powerchords. (We're D-beat raw punx)

>> No.43421664

guitar
bass
accordion
drums (not amazing at them though)
vocals (clean and harsh)
keyboard
harmonica

>> No.43421683
File: 600 KB, 929x622, 1389750996643.jpg [Show reposts] Image reverse search: [iqdb] [google]
43421683

>>43415377
>>43416002
harpsichord and ukulele. respect and baroque brofist to the lute guy

>> No.43421696

Guitar
Bass Guitar
Tin Whistle

>tfw no uilleann pipes
>tfw no diatonic accordion
>tfw no glockenspiel
>tfw no oboe
;_;

>> No.43421710

>>43421644
How did you learn how to play the chords?

>> No.43421731

>>43415377

skin flute

>> No.43421739

>>43421541
>>43421394
You're both being kids about this. I know professionals who can and can't read a lick of notes. I don't know any professionals who use that criteria in determining who they will and will not work with.

It's all about what works for you, and gets you the results you want. If you can't communicate an idea through the instrument to another musician, you're not very good at your instrument.

There are exceptions to this like alternative notation but anyone who truly wishes to partake in those things will learn them. That simple.

>> No.43421741

>>43421664
forgot banjo

>> No.43421770

Trombone, baritone, tuba, and bass.

>> No.43421773

>>43417784
find a piano student who haven't graduated from college yet. they will teach you for dinner. i know my mates take dinners for pay sometimes.

>> No.43421823

>>43421710
The powerchords? My brother taught me.

Mate... I never said I never had a teacher, the only thing i said was that you don't need to know chords or have had a teacher in order to play music, which you don't.

>> No.43421841

>>43421683
That's a beautiful instrument, what are those three small levers?

>> No.43421894

>>43421823
>he only thing i said was that you don't need to know chords or have had a teacher in order to play music, which you don't.
You do, you needed a teacher yourself (your brother).

>> No.43421900

Piano. Sometimes.

>> No.43422003

>>43421894
Yes

>> No.43422034

>>43422003
I'm glad you agree wiht me.

>> No.43422077

>ITT
>Retards who don't know shit about music act like they do

>> No.43422156

>>43422034
Thank you, I'm also glad

>> No.43422259

>>43422077
I can't speak for everyone in this thread, but I can say without a doubt that I "know shit" about music.

>> No.43422285

I'm self-taught, I don't see any advantages in it whatsoever, I only see the limits. My technical abilities have stagnated, no matter how much I practice, probably because I never learned proper technique and have no idea what I'm doing wrong; a teacher would've corrected this by physically moving and futzing around with my hands and fingers until they did things right.
I also try and teach myself as much about theory as I can, but as much as I've studied it over the years, I only have a faint grasp on the basics.
I don't think you need to know how to read music, but you definitely need to understand musical language when you're jamming with other people, you need to at least know what key you're in and how to play in time, and all that shit.
People see famous self-taught musicians and think that everyone can be that great, but the truth is those people are naturally talented and probably would've been even bigger had they been taught professionally.

>> No.43422302

>>43422259
Yes but did a teacher teach it to you?

>> No.43422444

>>43422302
Yeah. Are you implying that because I was taught things about music, I automatically don't know anything about music?
Because that would be, you know, a pretty dumb thing to assert.

>> No.43422469

>>43415377
i play cubase, fl studio, and ableton, also guitar a little bit

>> No.43422552

>>43422444
No, read the thread, you crouton.

>> No.43422594

>>43417200
but do you understand bass?

>> No.43422644
File: 56 KB, 400x512, 1389753014459.jpg [Show reposts] Image reverse search: [iqdb] [google]
43422644

Contrabass Clarinet
>pic related, le paperclip

>> No.43422663

>>43422552
I've been in this thread for a couple hours.
Not sure what point you were making when you asked if I've been taught or not.

>> No.43422790

>>43422663
I suppose it was in reference to the debate about a music teacher that went on through half of the thread. But since you've been here all along, well surely you would have known, right anon?

>> No.43422851

>>43422594
Rhythm and harmony. Typically playing the root and fifth, or walking arpeggiated scales.
Not hard at all, and all the "good" bassists you could possibly show anyone are people who play bass like lead guitar, which begs the question why they don't just play lead guitar.

>> No.43422866

If you haven't got a basic technical grounding you won't make decent music. you won't be able to construct chord structures cos you'll know crap all about voicings and you just won't end up producing something that's listenable.
this is generalising, there are obviously exceptions to every rule but some kind of theory/technical grounding is necessary when you wanna write stuff.
if you can play a note and sing a melody on top of it it's an indication that you'll progress quickly with teaching yourself. learn some keys. don't bother with scales. if you wanna write then to start with 5 or 6 chord sequences that you like is more than enough to be creative with the sounds.

if i sound upmyself it's because i'm tired. here's my soundcloud, feel free to tell me it's shit. there are fresh recordings coming soon. always interested in other people's stuff.

I play guitar piano and sing. i can drum a bit. use logic and ableton abit, been doing supercollider and max msp at university most recently.

>> No.43422920

MARY RAISED AND KILLED A LAMB

>> No.43422942

soundcloud = benrickard

>> No.43422994

I play Ableton and I'm a serious Massive geek

>> No.43423015
File: 26 KB, 643x482, 1389753727413.jpg [Show reposts] Image reverse search: [iqdb] [google]
43423015

french horn

pic related, proof that something besides a skin flute touches my mouth

>> No.43423031

>>43422790
I thought you were going to make a statement with a purpose rather than referencing the debate earlier in the thread.
I didn't pay much attention to the debate once I realized the anon who insists that self-taught musicians are of equal merit is a troll.
But if you want my opinion on the matter it's as follows:
Professionally trained musicians are, generally speaking, better than self-taught musicians. No, formal training doesn't restrict your creativity. No, being self-taught doesn't make you automatically inferior, but an understanding of how music works (theory) is inordinately helpful.
But still, most professional musicians don't even know how sound works.

>> No.43423099

>>43423031
See >>43420653

>> No.43423155

>>43423015
The only people I know that played the french horn were really really awkward kids. It's one of those instruments I feel isn't required at all, but included so the kid who plays it doesn't feel left out

>> No.43423232

>>43423099
I still don't see your point. I saw, and replied to, that post earlier.
(Amaj7/G sounds fairly lousy as a standalone chord on guitar. It might sound better on a piano, but I doubt it, as having the minor seventh in the bass fucks up the overtone series for the chord, plus having a G, G sharp, and an A in the same chord is going to cause incredible dissonance)

I've already stated that each type of musician has its own merits.

>> No.43423281
File: 43 KB, 559x690, 1389754174131.jpg [Show reposts] Image reverse search: [iqdb] [google]
43423281

I play guitar pretty alright. I can play/write a good melody or rhythm and can usually improvise well in a jam.
I'm not great, but I'm competent. I play an Ibanez acoustic outfitted with a surface contact piezo.
Pic related, the model guitar I play.
>inb4 pleb model- I am pooooooor

>> No.43423301

>>43423232
See >>43417129

>> No.43423315

i play ur mom's tits lol

>> No.43423407
File: 974 KB, 240x149, 1389754418396.gif [Show reposts] Image reverse search: [iqdb] [google]
43423407

>>43422851
you sound competent.

>> No.43423491

>>43423155
i started on percussion

it's plenty important you fuck, otherwise we wouldn't have shit like this (i'm only half kidding here):
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=lOSRwKkk9Jc

>> No.43423539

>>43422851
>all the "good" bassists you could possibly show anyone are people who play bass like lead guitar, which begs the question why they don't just play lead guitar.
I would contest that these bassists are in groups with lead guitarists already, and enjoy playing bass more than lead.
I personally enjoy more colorful bass lines than simple root notes and arpeggios/scales. Victor Wooten will be my favorite bass player until I actually learn anything about bass.

>> No.43423744

>>43415377
Piano
Guitar
Drums
Vocals
Cello
Theremin
musical DAW

>> No.43423779

>>43423155
>French horn
>Not required

ah well, I don't exactly expect /mu/ to be knowledgeable about music...

>> No.43424222

>>43423779
I've met too many terrible french horn players in my life to ever trust the french horn again.
Really good players make it sound wonderful, but it's so easy to make it sound like torture.

>> No.43424310

>>43424222
the French Horn is easily one of the hardest instruments to be found in popular music to master. Like, mind blowingly difficult.

>> No.43424327

Electric Bass
Guitar
Trumpet
Drums
Sampler/DAW

>> No.43424366

>>43424222
maybe if you fucking listened to any professional musical organization, ever, you wouldn't have that problem now would you? just wait til you graduate high school buddy, it gets better out there

>> No.43424450

>>43423744
you have any recorded music?

>> No.43424497

>>43421841
they're used to turn on and off different registers - you can have only one keyboard working, both at the same time, one played an octave higher than the other, basically different combinations. like with the organ

>> No.43424734

>>43424366
20 years old, spent 2 years as a music major. Fuck off.

>> No.43424735

>>43423155
>one of those instruments I feel isn't required at all
Well I'm going to go ahead and assume you've never been a part of an ensemble that's played classical music before.
>>43424222
listen to >>43424310, also I've heard a lot of awful guitar and piano but I'm not shutting them out of my life. Your logic on never trusting a french horn again is silly.
>>43416351
That sucks, can you at least double major? I have a friend who is in the same boat with a dance major and that was her out. If you can't, I honestly suggest you stick with it, and at least get a degree and a (even though it will probably be small) source of income.

>> No.43424831

>>43424734
cry harder

>> No.43424873

Shitty guitar and ukulele while I sing shitty Bowie covers.

>> No.43424941

>>43424831
Make me

>> No.43424981

Used to know how to play the cello and trombone, but I had a terrible music instructor that I wanted nothing to do with. And it just so happened she was fired a year after I quit.
Now there's not enough time or space to play big instruments anymore. I'm starting to wonder if I'm the only person on the planet who bought an ocarina to play things BESIDES Zelda songs

>> No.43426232

I just bought a drum kit so I'm trying to figure out what the fuck I should learn

>> No.43426519

>>43415987
Other than just studying it, any other way that would help me understand music theory? Sometimes I get more questions than answers when I dive into theory but Idk maybe it's just me.

>> No.43427391

>>43417200
>anyone that can play guitar can play bass

Yeah but most of them play it badly

>> No.43427417

Guitar, piano, saxophone, voice

>>
Name (leave empty)
Comment (leave empty)
Name
E-mail
Subject
Comment
Action