Let's get this shit going, /mu/
I really like Attention Please for some reason. Also listened to Vein today, so I should probably add that.
>>43134489pink is pretty accessible dude
>>43134580You're probably right, it's such a large discography that it get's confusing. Especially with how many of them have different versions.
We need Fearless extreme top left and ITAOTS just to the right of it.
>>43134387what a terrible chart
>>43134738>>43134387oops wrong image
>>43134738make a better one fag
>>43134693Speak Now >>> Fearless
>>43134572Laser Guided Melodies should be higher
>>43134788>>43134782
>>43134796One of the two, anyway.
>>43134782I don't feel like any of radio head should be that sort of 2deep4u mentality.
>>43134803>>43134572this put laser guided melodies in the top corner, lower lgwafis a bit, raise A&E, everything else is good
>>43134782>in rainbows that close to shit tier
cloud of albums, difficult to see because he's made so much stuff.
>>43134387>>43134782FTFY
>>43134489>>43134580Alright, added Smile and Vein and got it a little more accurate, Still not that accurate as I haven't listened to some of these albums enough.
>>43135409>radiohead that close to god tier
>>43134962Amnesiac not deep enough for you? Is it because the songs have some semblance of a melody and time signature?
worst thread ever
>>43135537Yeah here I show where I'd place them against each other rather than against every album ever.
>>43135580of all the shitty threads on /mu/, you say this one's the worst?
>>43135576Well, it's not even that. But it's not unique enough in its right to experimental type shit that falls in the term patrician.
well this took a while
Made this a few threads ago.
>>43135904you forgot eating us
>>43135995>quaristice>badit's not their best but it's pretty good
Here we go.
>>43134782>radiohead>deep
>>43135425>pink mroe accessible than heavy rocks 2002lol
>>43136457Pink is the most listened to album on last.fm by a long shot, I think that make's it more pleb.
The RDJ Twin
>>43136505thats only because pitchfork reviewed it and it scored well. heavy rocks is a more accessible album
someone do anco, i would but i'm on my phone
>>43135409Well I'll take a much better band which also is fairly respected here.
>>43135004>he's made so much stuffpretty much why i cant commit to moving past the glow pt. 2its so good and i know hes got more good stuff but theres soooooooooo much
>>43136679you really should though, he's by far my favorite musician.
>>43136664AccurateI dunno why "Help" is so high/close to God Tier though.
>>43136664>abbey road not their best>sgt. peppers not their second best
>>43136664Switch Help! with Magical Mystery Tour and switch Sgt. Pepper with Revolver and this would be accurate
>>43135904Move all of them down below the center line and it's correct
>>43136776Help has some of their best songs, and probably their best, "Yesterday".>>43136791I bet you hate their first records while you haven't even heard them, and your reason for hating them is>muh 4 chords. Punk and hip-hop rules thoughxD>>43136865God no.
>>43136628I'll never get this right.
the objective guide to kanye west
>>43135580Damn, looks like you meant to post that in the K pop thread.
>>43137089808s and LR should be higherbut other than that, accurate
>>43137089more like the p4k drone's guide
>>43137128Thought about it, but I think that LR hasn't aged as well as the other albums (except for mother fucking We Major) and 808s is only amazing in certain situations (like being sad, or wintertime).>>43137157>implying p4k never gets things right even by accidentEven a blind squirrel will eventually find a nut. They luck into it sometimes.
>>43137233what the fuck are you talking about
One I just finished
>>43137256It's lazy to argue that just because P4K gives a certain score to an album, that it must be wrong.
>mealica>2deep4u>god-tierlawl
>>43137089objectively wrong more like
>>43137326
>>43137216>RCA is patrician>FIOE is shit tier>Angles that low down>This is It being good>Room on fire that highall wrong nigger
>>43137338>implying the first four Metallica albums are anything less than legendary
Could someone make a Tim Hecker one?
>>43136988>I bet you hate their first records while you haven't even heard themWay to make a huge generalization to back up your argument.
>>43137354
Okay, who the fuck is posting Metallica Stop
>>43137389Despite how good they are they aren't patrician/deep/hard to grasp in any way
>>43135995q
>>43137471Seriously? Listen to "...And Justice for All", every song on the album is controversy to the Justice system, war, gov't, etc
>>43137517Ranting about government isn't a deep concept. Patrician =/= Edgy
>>43137372>>RCA is patricianYes, it is. Maybe you weren't able to understand it yet.>>FIOE is shit tierIt's the album in which they realise their old formula doesn't work anymore.>>Angles that low downThey started the rise that would led to their patrician masterpiece>>This is It being goodAOTD>>Room on fire that highMaybe it could be little lower, but without changing quadrant.
>>43137552The lyrics aren't cheesy and superficial, they have substance and concept.
>>43137602That's great. So does Madvillain, but that doesn't make it a deep album.
>>43137648Maybe I put them higher than they should be, but they're most certainly not closer to left than the right.
>>43136160>the understanding>shit tierfuck you it' a great album.way better than melody AM
>>43137517Every shitty punk bad in the world has written about that overused shit.Judging from that post, I'm inclined to believe that you're either 15 or from another board.
>>43137587accurate.
>>43137788>either 15 or from another boardwhynotboth.jpg
>>43135904What's the album in the top right corner?
>>43138458You have the self-titled and Deceit mixed up bruv.
Someone please make a MF DOOM one, with all his names.
>>43138494I might have agreed at one point, but over the last year I've come of the opinion that Deceit is one of the best albums of rock or popular music ever made.s/t is a little more patrician, but Deceit is the better album.
>>43138458Swap s/t and Deceit and you've got yourselfa nice chart.
Didn't include the spaghetties for obv reasons
>>43139100>Guns n' Roses>deep>good at all
>>43139143>implyging AfD isnt the greatest debut album of all timelel m8
>>43139100move that shit all to the bottom left
>>43134419But Combat Rock and London Calling and Sandinista! are way more accessible than Give Them Enough Rope and The Clash
>>43139208Lel, the answer to that would be Faust m8.
>>43138194Good one, but Lift Your Skinny Fists should be higher than Slow Riot. Slow Riot is pretty entry level GY!BE and doesn't have the energy of Skinny Fists. Also, I always thought Yanqui UXO wasn't very good, but everybody seems to enjoy it, so I guess it has its place in the God Tier.
>>43139726And the follow up
>>43135725>tfw ghosts is your favorite NIN project
>>43135004Ocean Roar and Don't Wake Me Up should be higher. Clear Moon should switch with No Flashlight. Black Bird should definitely be less accessible.
>>43139532>>43139100get the fuck out
>>43138458Relative to experimental post-punk, This Heat is extremely accessible
>>43139968I can't think of hardly any post-punk bands that were as successfully experimental as This Heat.There might have been a few "lol so wierd i dont even" bands, but This Heat had the best ratio of excellent to innovative of any group I can recall.
>>43139208That is exactly what I'm implying.Here are some bands that have better debut albums:SwansAnimal CollectiveKornFleet FoxesMewLamb of God65daysofstaticCoheed and CambriaThis Town Needs GunsNeutral Milk HotelSlipknotThe list could go on
>>43134387>he thinks KoL is 2deep
>>43135004This would be right if you mirrored it around the vertical axis
>>43135995Tri Repetae is pretty accessible tho
>>43137089>808s that 2deep4ulolno
>>43137290lol
>>43134457>Year of the Tiger 2nd bestFuck yeah. That EP is the shit.
This chart excludes their Christmas albums (both of which are God-tier in Christmas music regardless) and albums consisting of rereleased/rerecorded material.
>>43139100Okay I like Guns N' Roses and all but it's just downright foolish to post it on /mu/. And none of it, absolutely NONE of it belongs anywhere near 2deep4uAlso, Use Your Illusion I is better than Use Your Illusion II so separate them. Use Your Illusion has Estranged, that's it.
>>43140160>slipknot>not joking
>>43136355I snorted
>>43137128die
I hope I'm not too late
>>43135004winds poem should be up at glow pt. 2 level
>>43136355accurate
>>43135004>it was hot more accessible than winds poem
just made this
>>43139775You and me both
>>43144185This chart is diseased.
put the titles of the albums somewhere so that you can easily identify the album if you don't know the band
>>43143553I would make The Seer much lower on the quality scale, and make The Great Annihilator higher in quality and slightly more to the left, but otherwise I agree completely
>>43134309
>>43144339it's not that hard to find the album cover via wikipedia
>>43143293This is 100% accurate.
>>43138525of the one's i've listened to here's mine. i mad it pretty quickly
>>43137587>afraid of heights>not god-tier
How about an Aquabats thread?
>>43144659how is dangerdoom the most 2deep4u what
>>43144730fuck that mtv shit
>>43144780cause it adult swim fanfici kinda see your point thoughalso making that inspired me to finally listen to born like this and goddamn why did i wait so long?
>>43136988>Yesterday>not one of their worstlel
>>43139532agreed but it should be all the way to the left
>>43136608>drukqs that far downshould be top right somewhere because that shit sure as hell aint accessible
>>43139570f#a# was bretty shit tho
>>43137290>kill em all>black album>same level of accessibility
>>43138255tobacco - allegheny white fish tapes
yep
>>43137552i wish godspeed fans understood this
>>43145009nah
>>43145157this would only be a blow at their music if deep concept = good, which it doesn't. efrim is pretty aware of that i think too. he was super friendly and talkative to the crowd when i saw thee silver mt zion
>>43137587suprisingly accurate
>>43145118Damn I forgot to do an actual Pink Floyd chart
>>43143020Slipknot is pretty goodI said it.
>>43143293b-butI love Three Imaginary Boys;__;
>>43145118top kek
This was hard, enjoy, my friends.
>>43145219objectively
>>43143553Pretty good, I might bump Filth and drop The Seer a little but otherwise I can't complain.
>>43145499you still managed to fuck it upit should be way closer to accessible than 2deep4you
>>43145443I agree with this more than anything else in this thread. I would just move amnesiac up more and the bends down a little.
>>43145694That is acceptable. I'm glad we have correct opinions.
>>43145499>didn't include burst apartI approve, it's less than shit tier
i tried
>>43145359i find it boring and kinda masturbatory (like they didn't know what they were doing and just messed around in his mom's garage or something), sorry
>>43145879>piper that low>final cut that high
>>43145929piper is a piece of shit but to be fair so is the final cut
>>43145879final cut is good but piper should be right up there with it, as well as atom heart mother.
>>43137216accurate
>>43145879You're a fucking disgrace to Floydians. AHM is shit? Srsly listen more.
>>43146201lol where is everything?
>this many posts>no anco
>>43146356Haven't listened to all their eps :/
>>43146372get on it, dude.
>>43146408>danse that low>campfire songs that low>sung tongs that far to the righttry again
>>43146408move spirit higher and sung tongs lower and then i agree.
>>43146408>spirit that far to the right>strawberry jam that high>mpp as far left as feels
>>43134877Beyond should be a lot closer to God-Tier.
>>43146487>feels as far left as mpp
>>43143553>any swans album being on the accessible side
>>43145820Not too shabby, anon. But Hot Rats should be a little higher. And if you're feeling masochistic, make another one including his live albums.
>>43137216CM should be the only one below the line, all rest are good where they are, but move FIoE just above Angles.
Introducing the Zero-Trolling Edition
>>43137290kind of yeah I can see that
>>43146973you still got it wrong
>>43137587>accessible = shittybasically how mu thinks
>>43147014Not the same person who posted the other charts. Oh yeah and I admit I forgot to lower all the albums in the upper left quadrant.
>>43145879Does the soundtrack to More really have this bad of a reputation? I've always quite liked it.
>>43137290I would put "Metallica" a lot closer to the accessible part, but other than that it's a pretty great chart.
>>43139968>This Heat>extremely accessible
why is the font in comic sans
>>43147162because /mu/ is a cesspool and deserves no better
undisputed truth
>>43146822I think that makes sense, since it's obviously curtailed to the band's standards.But The Seer is not accessible wtf lol especially not more then fucking The Burning World that makes no sense.also the burning world isn't that bad.
>>43145703ONE TWO THREE FOUR WE MUST LOCK THE DOOR FIVE SIX SEVEN EIGHT WE MUST EVACUATE NINE TEN ELEVEN TWELVE WE MUST PREPARE FOR THIRTEEN MONSTERS THIRTEEN MONSTERS ONE TWO THREE FOUR WE MUST LOCK THE DOOR FIVE SIX SEVEN EIGHT WE MUST EVACUATE NINE TEN ELEVEN TWELVE WE MUST PREPARE FOR THIRTEEN MONSTERS THIRTEEN MONSTERS ONE TWO THREE FOUR WE MUST LOCK THE DOOR FIVE SIX SEVEN EIGHT WE MUST EVACUATE NINE TEN ELEVEN TWELVE WE MUST PREPARE FOR THIRTEEN MONSTERS THIRTEEN MONSTERS ONE TWO THREE FOUR WE MUST LOCK THE DOOR FIVE SIX SEVEN EIGHT WE MUST EVACUATE NINE TEN ELEVEN TWELVE WE MUST PREPARE FOR THIRTEEN MONSTERS THIRTEEN MONSTERS
>>43147162same reason your sentence doesn't end with a period.
Surprised nobody did AFX yet
>>43147499see>>43136608
>>43147545Well fuck
>>43137089>Kanye>Anywhere on the right
>>43144162>wrong generation
>>43138318Ferris Wheel is my favourite too.Also I'd switch the height of Aeroplane and Avery Isle
>>43147294>Homogenic not on topThe rest is legit tho
>>43147294False
>>43147809>Larks Tongues lower than ItCotCK>In the Wake of Poseidon >Deep>Discipline so low and left>Islands so low>Lizard not Lower>Red not higher>ItWoP not lower>Starless not more left
>>43147809how is in the wake of poseidon deep?
>>43147499>SAW2 close to shit tier
>>43147928Not trying to be edgy. Just not my type. This shart is everything but objective but hey we're talking about afx here
>>43147897Medulla is just as good as Homogenic and Vespertine. Otherwise pretty similar to mine. Also you have The Sugarcubes there, but no Gling Glo. :(
>>43147809ftfy
>>43147961i mainly disagreed with your ranking of volta as her lowest albumalso no idea what gling glo is but>checkin' it out
>>43144730>steve from blues cluesholy fuck, you killed me, anon
>>43143553Greed, Holy Money, Cop, and Filth shouldn't be that close to "shit tier"Asides from that, this is quite accurate.
>>43139100Guns N Roses is an awful band.So awful that I need to post this even though it will not be read.They are the worst band. Ever.
>>43147332all of them should be bottom left
>>43146973>TFC and AMLOR more accessible than The Wall and DSOTM>Piper that highwhat the fuck is this
ITT: people who can't handle the fact that people don't always share their opinions
>>43148551Basically
>>43148802>CCIII>experimental>good
>>43148551welcome to 4chan, enjoy your stay
>>43138194I'd say Yanqui UXO is more 2deep4u than F*A* Infinity.
Why are Faust so damn interesting? They never seem pretentious or "over-experimental" even though they're probably the most lo-fi, game changing and different band out there. What a charm on those guys.
>>43144659Where's Mr Hood?Also DANGERDOOM should be all the way to the left.
>>43143293>head on the door lower than wish
>>43148286>Power Corruption Lies not all the way to the leftSwap it and Technique around, then we'll talk. Also Get Ready shouldn't be that fucking low, it was alright.
>>43148963>not including their best album
>>43146973lookin good bb
>>43148933what makes all the comps accessible?
>>43149033Man, I love Tony Cornrod
>>43149066They've all got their highest charting singles on them, that's why.That, and no filler
>>43149033Didn't even know of this album, will definetly check it out. Wow I see this is from the 70's, fucking looking forward to this.
>>43149143they also collaborated with Slapp Happy on this too (1973), it's also pretty good
>>43149187>Foals>Goodtop pleb
>>43148933>s/t lower than anything else
>>43148987Head on the Door has all the weird crappy children's tv show music with the synth-flutes in the middle of it
>>43149009>implying PCL is their most accessible albumThat's probably one of the weirdest things I've ever heard anyone say
>>43149207pretentious fuck
>>43149185Will listen to this after I'm done with >>43149033, so far I really like the songwriting on this. Can already hear that this isn't as good as their first though.
>>43149280As if Technique is their most accessible?
Bumping with another great German progressive rock band.
>>43149323I think you need to look at the chart closer
>>43149528Quite accurate but i will move everything a bit lower
>>43149528>having a positive opinion of Coldplay on /mu/what the fuck are you trying to do here
my piss-poor attempt at thisi probably clustered them too close tho
>>43149737>4chan is one big hivemind and if you don't agree, you don't belongsrsly, people like are truly the CANCER killing 4chan
>>43149787
>>43136355oh jeeze I spit out my humus
>>43149787this
>>43150200What?
>>43150212Problem?
>>43150233That's not even the same band you tard. Look at literally every other submission to this thread.
>>43150247God damnit. My bad. Brb going to kill myself
>>43150258It's okay, don't do it again.
>>43137089I really don't get the hate surrounding Bound 2, or even the video itself. Really just looks like he's placing himself in a bunch of stereotypical white-American archetypes and it's kind of hilarious, anyone care to explain?
>>43150258Good. No one should think Shout at the Devil is THAT good. Too Fast for Love on the other hand...
>>43146201TH is greatThere I said it
>>43149787>liking bad band
>>43150334They're both great. I'm actually listening to TFFL right now
>>43150413>MSABAF that right
>>43150434Yeah, kind of.>Warning Sign>Artists Only>Stay Hungry>I'm Not in LoveNot very accessible songs, especially compared to their other stuff.
>>43150459All of those songs are pretty accessible, like 77 tier accessible
>>43150258>>43150233>>43150200qualified retard
>>43150497Maybe my perception of accessibility has been skewed since coming to /mu/, but I when I made the chart I was thinking that Byrne's vocals on those tracks might deter some people. But then again they might deter people on anything he sings.
>>43150413>where is remain in light>finally see it>mfw
>>43149437spot on
this didnt really work
>>43135995it's perfect
>>43136664>Magical Mystery >Shit
>>43145879I actually kind of agree with this one. I'd move a few albums around, but overall, not bad.
opeth
>>43150705even Blaze's albums?Even Dance of Death?Even No Prayer for the Dying?Even the fucking Blaze albums?Even Iron Maiden has bad albums
>>43144143how did you come to that conclusion?look at the picture again.
>>43137290That chart is flawless
>>43150814dance of death is probably the bestblaze albums are better than killers and prayer for the dying and final frontier and fear of the darkeven killers and prayer for the dying are still kinda good
jefferson airplane
>>43150805actually ive decided they should all probably be shifted about 20% leftwards, opeth is fairly accessible, atleast as a 'death metal' band goes
because I've been listening to the EP collection and I felt like it.
>>43150874This is a music board, not a comedy board. Please keep the jokes to yourself.
>>43150890But...but...Number of the Beast
>>43145879If I met you in person I'd hate you. Meddle should be way higher along with piper and AHM, Final cut lower, saucerful further right and up, and Ummagumma actually included
>>43150953number of the beast and powerslave and somewhere in time and seventh son and brave new world and dance of death are all about even at the top
>>43146973Everything could be shifted around slighty and Meddle should be higher
>>43146822I'd agree on early Swans but their post-rock stuff is fairly accessible.>>43138194f#a# that far more to the right than LYSF? really?
his main three pieces of work. couldn't fit all of them on this chart otherwise.
>>43143553Cop up, Filth up, Holy Money and Greed WAY upWhite Light way down, Seer Down, Soundtracks down a bitTheir first 5 and then Soundtracks are the best
>>43145118put Animals above DSOTM, just by a bit, and I'll agree with you
>>43147294Biophilia down, SelmaSongs down, Homogenic up
>>43147897>Volta that high>Post and Debut that low>Medulla that low
I hope this arc doesn't continue with the next record
>>43151206I got really excited when I saw where Division Bell was but then I saw Momentary Lapse and Final Cut
>>43151436their new songs haven't sounded that good..