[ cgl / con / g / mu / qa / w ] [ index / top / reports / FAQ / DAAS / IG / status / transparency / fuuka ] [ img-search ]
As Dark As My Soul Default Fuuka

/mu/ - Music (Temp full images)


View post   

File: 82 KB, 445x567, 12.jpg [Show reposts] Image reverse search: [iqdb] [google]
40841979 No.40841979 [Reply] [Original]

Is ska objectively the worst genre of music?

I mean, it's genuinely made BY plebs, FOR plebs. The whole thing is completely stale.

>> No.40842026

I wouldn't say the worst (that would probably have to be crunkcore or something), but ska is pretty bad

>> No.40842049

modern ska is crap but post punk is worse
proper ska is great

>> No.40842050

rave

>> No.40842055

HOLY GUACAMOLE, WE GOT CHIPS!

>> No.40842068

>>40842049
as in the reggae offshoot?

>> No.40842088

I want to say pop-punk buuuuuut
maybe nu-metal?

>> No.40842089

>>40842068
ska came before reggae. it would be more accurate to say that reggae is an offshoot of ska

>> No.40842104

The Specials and Madness are pretty good though.

>> No.40842105

>>40842088
What's wrong with pop punk?

>> No.40842118

HC punk
Skate punk
Nu metal

I grew up in the late 90s. Can you imagine a time when people thought Tool is sophisticated music? I'm so glad the hipster revolution swept away all that 90s caveman bullshit.

>> No.40842120

>>40842105
lol

>> No.40842127

I really like Less Than Jake and Mighty Mighty Bosstones. Hate me if you want. Sublime is trash though

>> No.40842137

>>40842120
That doesn't sound like an answer

>> No.40842142

the worst genre of music is hopeless modern rock bands desperately trying to bring back the hard rock sound of the 60s and 70s

think wolfmother

fucking embarassing

please let rock music die

>> No.40842157

>>40842118
Tool is neither of the genres you mentioned

>> No.40842169

>>40842137
kids like it so its bad
we must shame our middle school selves and their tastes constantly to convince ourselves of some sense of growth

>> No.40842174

>>40842105
Oh come on, its cheesy and awful. I cant imagine anyone over the age of 12 enjoying it.

>> No.40842177

>>40842105
i haven't listened to much but the lyrics are terribly cheesy, the culture it created is among the worst on earth, and to me the guitar parts are very copy and paste

>> No.40842181

>>40842157
Tool is nu-metal as fuck man, can't you hear it?

>> No.40842187

>>40842157
Tool is nu metal. Angsty, jumpdafuqup, crotch-grabbing, white trash nu metal.

>> No.40842190

>>40841979
Crunkcore.

If you disagree that this isn't the worst genre of music, you are objectively a terrible person.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=N8F5YSA1Oz0

Click at your own risk, you might get cancer.

>> No.40842197

>>40842169
could you project any harder?
it's literal shit

>> No.40842211

Hard rock is pretty bad.

>> No.40842216

>>40842190
are you absolutely sure this isn't ironic?
i burst out laughing

>> No.40842221

>>40842181
>>40842187

>Tool
>Nu-metal

Tool is just crappy poppy experimental metal. Not nu metal but it's terrible anyways.

>> No.40842222

deathcore
post-grunge
whatever FFDP is

>>40842157
reread his post, he wasn' implying that at all

>> No.40842232

>>40842190
thanks this music gave me cancer.

>> No.40842238

Pop punk is the most horrific forms of commodification I have seen. Take punk, something so bluntly reactionary to commodification, niche marketing, and capitalism, and then market it to teenagers as using these three things in the process. It's dishonest, insincere, musically uninteresting, and borderline offensive.

>> No.40842240

>>40842216
No it isn't ironic, brah. It's crunkcore, it's screamo and pop music.

>> No.40842247

crunkcore or whatever teenage emo girls call blood on the dance floor these days

>> No.40842257

No one has mentioned trance, techno, and similar oonce oonce braindead bullshit. I tried watching a documentary about the techno fandom yesterday, but I couldn't cause the idea of people listening to techno was too repulsive for me.

>> No.40842258

>>40842190
it makes me laugh every time. if this had been riding the ironic wave, people would have been all over it.

>> No.40842262

>>40842257
I'm not sure you fully understand what techno is.

>> No.40842264

>>40842181
Im pretty sure its a progressive metal.

>> No.40842277

>>40842238
my nigga

>> No.40842281

NN-DUH NN-DUH NN-DUH NN-DUH NN-DUH

there i just did every single ska rhythm that has ever existed

dont forget to talk about california, weed, and peace

>> No.40842290

>>40842238
Is that a scaruffi quote?

>> No.40842299

modern "post-hardcore" is a contender

>> No.40842311

>>40842197
Probably could since I never listened to the genre to begin with though
The genre I liked in middle school was nu-metal and I still indulge on occasion.

>> No.40842313

>>40842262
Techno is the lowest form of music. It is the idea that music can be reduced to the number of beats per second. Techno is the sound of a rhythm machine and not much more.

>> No.40842320

>>40842290
sounds too reasonable to be a scaruffi quote

>> No.40842321

>>40842290
No

>> No.40842335

>>40842313
I feel like you've probably never listened to actual techno and are just referring to whatever generic EDM you have heard as such

>> No.40842336

Guitar music. ANYTHING with a guitar. It's an outdated instrument and only edgy underage metal fags and emo rockers enjoy guitar music. Grow up, this isn't the 80s, you mallgoth pieces of shit. Guitar music is dead.

>> No.40842345

>>40842257
go away, henry rollins
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=AyRDDOpKaLM

>> No.40842358

>>40842335
why are you responding to bait?

>> No.40842393

>>40842336
true, but there are still recordings from the 70s that can reminds us of the time when pop music reached its' indisputable peak and guitar virtuosos were cropping up everywhere. The incompetent, tech-reliant musicians of today are but a mere shadow of the olympian age of the early 70s.

>> No.40842417

pop punk

>> No.40842419

>>40842393
>Guitar virtuosos.

Claiming you're good at the guitar is just as impressive as claiming you're good at playing WoW.

It's pathetic.

>> No.40842425

>>40842358
this whole thread is bait, all threads which are about whats bad or worst are are. the game is you try and get in snarky comments about stuff you dont like, but you cant go too far because if anyone says something truly retarded they can be made to look stupid.

>> No.40842428

>>40842336
>ANYTHING with a guitar
I think this goes a bit too far, not everything with a guitar is automatically bad

>> No.40842434

>>40842425
Ska is genuinely 100% shit though.

>> No.40842436

>>40842419
It's actual artistry, unlike being good at twiddling knobs and posing with headphones on.

>> No.40842455

>>40842336
I don't see how it could be dead, when it's still probably as popular as its ever been

>> No.40842473
File: 38 KB, 300x300, Streetlight_Manifesto_-_Everything_Goes_Numb[1].jpg [Show reposts] Image reverse search: [iqdb] [google]
40842473

Ska sucks but these guys are cool, right?

>> No.40842485

>>40842436
>Guitar music
>Art

Compare:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=V90Nkmyj5s0

to

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=DPyOhP1GTRQ

Guitar music is retardedly simple.

>> No.40842501

>>40842336
>>40842455
I wonder if in ~30 years time this will actually be the case. Guitars will be nothing more than antique collector's items and anyone trying to actually base any music around a riff structure will be ridiculed. Then there would be some bullshit "rock revival" movement as awful as the current one.

>> No.40842518

>>40842485
>complexity is the be-all end-all of music

you are the dream theater fan of electronic music. castrate yourself.

>> No.40842520

>>40842473
They're alright. Mostly mediocre.

>> No.40842522

>>40842358
>>40842335
People who listen to electronica really do delude themselves that all electronic music isn't just a 4x4 beat and a monotonous throbbing sound which they confuse with bass.

>> No.40842530

>>40842434
no see youre doing it wrong because I know youve never listened to any 60s jamaican ska and are basing your trolling on your reaction to the revival stuff so I cant take you seriously. youve got to be more subtle, detailed and accurate.
this is a good example of someone who knows how to play >>40842238

>> No.40842538

>>40842501
yeah, like classical music, right? dead and antique!

>> No.40842581

>>40842538
I get what you mean but classical fans are usually 40+ adult men with no comprehension of modern music and tryhard students
It's a niche market

>> No.40842626

>>40842581
but every time classical influences pop up in any song ever, the praise piles up. sure, I can definitely see rock and guitar music becoming something seen as quaint, but I don't think it will be ridiculed, far from it.

>> No.40842698

>>40842473
Al least post Catch 22

>> No.40842719

>>40842336
the only problem with guitars is that they're primarily used for rock music. it's a cool sounding instrument and i play one but it sounds so much better in jazz or classical stuff

>> No.40842772

>>40842257
You don't know what techno is. It's one of the harder genres to really get a grasp of the sound. Trance is pretty bad though, but it used to be good like about 15 years ago

>> No.40842793

>>40842719
Jazz is the epitome of boring, uncreative shit that has sounded the same since the 50s. Jazz may have been good once, but that was during WWII at the latest. Rock may have been stunted and degraded by the emergence of punk and metal, but it's a surprisingly mutable and varied form, far more than jazz.

>> No.40842815

anybody who dislikes Madness should be killed

>> No.40842827

>>40842793
>implying jazz didn't completely change as the 60s ended and the 70s started
>implying pre-50s jazz is worth anything

you're talking out of your ass

>> No.40842963

>>40842793
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9mXr43szbYY
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ScME4cv2qXI
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7K3-ug6Qgfg
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ZfrmfF-oX84

You're a musical simpleton if you don't hear a clear difference between each of those.

>> No.40843011

The best trumpet player I've ever met in my life played in a ska band. I don't know how you can pretend that an entire genre is devoid of all musical talent because you don't like the sound of the final product.

>> No.40843024

I never got the hate for ska on /mu/. Sublime are shit, yes, but how can people not like The Aquabats? Mustard Plug? Madness?

Do you all just hate fun or something?

>> No.40843075

There is no artistry in playing the same guitar riff over and over

There is no artistry in repeating lyrics over a standard hip hop beat

I feel like I'm trapped in a neverending spiral of two evils

PLz

>> No.40843084

>>40842518
fucking this. I love me some technical death-metal and dissonant avant-garde shit but lots of it is also shit. I'd take Burzum over 'Igorrr' any day

>> No.40843103

>>40843024
Its not moody, depressing, abrasive or alternative enough.

>> No.40843198

>>40842190
Much like how the ancients did not "get" rock and roll, or how the rock and roll generation didn't "get" electronic/90's pop... You just don't get it grandpa.

Give it a few years and the people who get it will find it and give it fame all while you get left behind by the flow of time.

>> No.40843269

>>40843024
Sublime aren't shit though. Their first two releases were pretty damn good actually. Lyrical depth isn't necessarily there, but they made some pretty experimental tracks and were generally fun to listen to.

>> No.40843276

>>40843198
Just because something's new doesn't mean it's good.

>> No.40843284

>>40842345
I guess he wouldn't enjoy plunderphonics.

>> No.40843305

The only real time ska sounds good is when you're in California high as fuck, which is really all it takes to make ska in the first place. But I'm not implying all ska is bad, some ska bands have my ok, like I went to the Caribbean last year and in almost every bar I went to there was an indie ska band playing and I gotta say, they were pretty good

>> No.40843316

>>40841979
Listen to Ghost Town. Ska IS overall one of the worst genres of music, but Ghost Town is a phenomenal song.

>> No.40843323

>>40842127
mein neger
Less Than Jake and Bosstones are the only ska I listen to

>> No.40843327

>>40843276
Just because something doesn't appeal to you doesn't mean it has no appeal to anyone.

>> No.40843340

>>40842216
Not in the least

>> No.40843458
File: 299 KB, 1600x1231, ExclusiveAquabatsHallwayImage[1].jpg [Show reposts] Image reverse search: [iqdb] [google]
40843458

Hi /mu/.

Aquabats got budget for 3 more TV episodes(that's 3 new songs.)

What are you going to do?

>> No.40843597

>>40843458
Celebrate

>> No.40843634

>>40843597
The fuck is wrong with you?

>> No.40843791

>>40843597
3/10

>> No.40843818

>>40843634
I like fun.

>> No.40843878

>>40842473
One of the few post two-tone bands that got ska right along with Aquabats, early Catch 22, Big D and all of Jeff Rosenstock's bands

>> No.40843879

>>40842174
Old older brother, now in is early 30's, loves Green Day.

>> No.40843899

>>40843879
My older brother*
what the fuck

>> No.40843948

>>40843818
It's LITERALLY music for kids.

ON TOP of being ska.

>> No.40843992

>>40843948
Yeah

And it's fun

>> No.40844004
File: 37 KB, 527x359, 1303685948573.jpg [Show reposts] Image reverse search: [iqdb] [google]
40844004

Most people who say Ska is bad have never listened to first wave ska

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Ef7bCWyCvIE

>> No.40844008

>>40843948
Actually Aquabats started out being a semi-ironic band aimed towards teenagers.

>> No.40844010

Most of Ska treats music as a joke or a medium of comedy. They don't take the art seriously so no one can take them seriously. Which results in a shallow genre. But it still isn't the worst. Just really close to the bottom.

>> No.40844011

>>40843948
>the complexity of The Aquabats' "Pizza Day" in which the narrator laments the loss of his youth and a period of time in his life when things were easy and he was cared for, and his only concern was waiting for the next pizza day
>for kids

>> No.40844018

>>40843458
Pizza Party

>> No.40844038

>>40842049
>post punk is worse
don't be a fag

>> No.40844042

>>40844008
>teenagers
Yeah.
Kids.

>> No.40844113

>>40844018
>>40844011
Making music for manchildren is arguably even worse.

>> No.40844162

>>40842142
Yeah, even just the name is cringeworthy.

>> No.40844175

>>40843284
I dunno, it seemed like his main complaint was how dumbed down and repetitive lots of so-called "rave" music is
If someone showed him something more varied and layered like The Avalanches, he'd probably be able to at least appreciate it

>> No.40844209

>>40844113
If being an artist was as easy as making music for X or Y, everyone would be making critically and mainstream acllaimed music. Shamefully, that's not the case, and we have a word for that. It's 'posseur'. Music should first and foremost be honest about the artist and what they want to communicate. Nothing's lamer than a 40 year old rockstar who spent his youth doing drugs and getting drunk as shit, suddenly trying to cash in on the popularity of angst by making slow, shoegazey music. That's what The Aquabats are. The music is fun and energetic, and the message is honest. I don't know what your problem is.

>> No.40844230

>>40844175
I said that based on the way how he bashed using samples and remixing and shit. He sounds like he has pretty narrow and generic view on electronic music in general. Which is fine, considering his background.

>> No.40844262

>>40844209
>That's what The Aquabats are
a staple against*

>>
Name (leave empty)
Comment (leave empty)
Name
E-mail
Subject
Comment
Action