Their masterpiece?
>inb4 232 replies, PATGOD is their best, and CLT banging on Roger Waters
I don't think so but atleast it's better than dark side
I remember being 13 too, OP!
It was the first Pink Floyd album I ever bought and listened to.
do you even scaruffi?
whats that? i cant hear you over how much better animals is
I'd say it's their most feelworthy, with The Final Cut at second in that regard. But TFC is more of a Waters solo album than a Pink Floyd album.
Yes.
>>32928483this. Everything done after Syd left is shit.
Never been that big of a fan of Welcome to the Machine.
That's not Animals
>>32928469Why do you say that?
>>32928733>saucerful>ummagumma>atom heart mother>shit
>>32928803It's the standard contrarian /mu/tard response to PF.
>>32928733I don't understand this sentiment. I get why you'd think Piper is the best, but why do you think Waters' stuff is shit?
>>32928849>saucerful>goodapart from that last track that features, Syd, it's shit.
>>32928886Pleb>MUH SYD
>>32928381Yeah OP. I've never understood why people give so much more attention to DSOTM than this. I guess this isn't as psychedelic.
The Final Cut is quickly becoming my favorite of them.
>>32928949The Final Cut is terribly underrated, if you ask me.
>>32928884because Syd was the true genius in the band. The only one that could capture the talent within every member and use it to make his colorful imagination blossom.
>>32928949>liking anything by pink floyd after animals
>>32928975Yeah yeah yeah Syd was the best, I get it. Answer the question. Why is Waters' material shit?
>>32928987>liking anything by pink floyd after piper
>>32929036See>>32928849
>>32928974It would had been viewed higher if the word Pink Floyd was not slapped onto the album.
>>32928975>true genius in the band>not Richard Wright
>>32928886Hahahahaha. Oh wow. Seriously? The only mediocre song on that album is See-Saw.>>32928987>implying The Final Cut is a pleb album
>>32928803Because the only people who still pretend to like Pink Floyd are old farts, and 13 year olds trying way too hard to impress their dads. God help you if you don't sit in one of those 2 categories.
>>32929104>implying The Final Cut is a pleb albumIt is
>>32928974Fletcher Memorial Home > Southampton Dock > The Final CutIt's a perfect succession of songs in my opinion. I always get stuck on those 3 when listening all the way through.
>>32929019Waters was hogging the spotlight and not leting anyone else write songs. Instead he should have used everyones talents in the band to create a materpiece of an album.
>>32929019Waters is the worst, dude. I get why you could find Gilmour interesting, but Waters is just a cunt. There's absolutely no flavor to any of his compositions.
>>32928381you probably think that shine on is their best song too. eh OP?
>>32928987>Implying the Wall did not have some of the best works of Pink FloydNot talking about the album as a whole.
>>32929105What are you if you don't sit in that category?
>>32929105Go away, /mu/ stereotype.
>>32929152It didn't
>>32929135The Gunner's Dream makes me crei evertim
>>32929097Go to bed CLT
>>32929105i think its time you stop posting
>>32929097Richard was great. Probably the second most significant member of the band, but Syds style of writing was something else.
>>32929097Uh... He's cool. But without Syd to lead his talent to the right direction, he wouldn't have shone so much.
>>32929147Nope.That'd be Echoes or Dogs.
>>32929152>Wall>being a pink floyd album
>>32929162Someone who genuinely enjoys Pink Floyd (aka someone w/ shit taste).
>>32929188>implyingI realised this long before I even knew /mu/ existed.
>>32929187
>>32929199Dogs is alright.sadly i can't say the same thing for echoes.
>>32929167>Implying Comfortably Numb and Hey you is not one of their best songs>Implying Mother, Good bye blue skies, Is their any body out their, no one home, and The trial are also good songs.
>>32929264Really? I started to outgrow Pink Floyd about 5 or 6 years ago but I still think Echoes is fucking beautiful.
>>32929293Comfortably numb sure is good, that album sure sucks ass
>implying this isn't their greatest release.
>>32929358Ummagumma version is superior
>>32929293>>32929152I think we can all agree that The Wall worked much better as a movie than an album. With The Trial being one of the greatest film scenes of anything ever.
>>32929312i generally find echoes dull, bland and painfully generic.but still that is my opinion.
>>32929371>implying Point Me At The Sky is on Ummagumma>implying Secrets isn't their best live album
>>32929401>The Trial being one of the greatest film scenes of anything ever.I was politely ignoring this thread until now, but FUCK no.
>>32929414I dunno, I see it more as the feeling of being suspended in an ocean and slowly sinking downwards, then finally emerging towards the surface and the morning sun.
>>32929430Secrets is damn good on Pompeii also.
>>32929455I say taste is subjective. You say its objective. Yeah, just leave. We all know youre biased against Waters.
>>32929455C'mon, it's a masterpiece of animation and the music is pretty good..in a musical theater sort of way.
>>32929521I don't think you know what "bias" means.>>32929526>it's a masterpiece of animationmy sides>and the music is pretty good..in a musical theater sort of wayIt sounds like a rejected Dresden Colls cut.
>>32929521CLT has never said taste is objective
>>32929472well, i think they try so hard to create something that may be qualified as space-ambient.there are dozens of bands in krautrock and progressive electronic scene that made it far more better than pink floyd and when you try to compare them with pf you see that how it fits.just listen tangerine dream's rubycon. then you will see what floating actually means in any form.
>>32929199I like sheep more than dogs, but the whole album is great
>>32929414>dull, bland and painfully genericBuzzwords general?
>>32929785these are the words that sums up echoes completely.
>>32929874but that's wrong
>>32929874You could say that about any album if you wanted to
>>32929874Explain why.
>>32929637I understand that you wouldn't like the music but you don't think that Gerald Scarfe's animation is well done?
>>32929895but quite right for me.>>32929905yes, but i choose to describe echoes
>>32930009That's fine, but it isn't a very good argument.
>>32929958where do you want me to start?
>>32929975No, but I wouldn't call it a masterpiece either. I'm pretty conservative with that term.
Just stating that The Final Cunt is an abysmal album. Holy fuck,why did Roger decide that the world needed another album filled with his edgy traumatic experiences?