eeeh, I prefer the original. Whole Lotta Love was better as Hey Joe, The Lemon Song makes me cringe the fuck out, Thank You is not as pretty and wonderful as it seems on the first couple listens (and it's certainly not the better iteration of Your Time Is Gonna Come)... Plant's screams were better and had more impact on any I song than its II counterpart. Ramble On was the beginning of a questionable path for Zeppelin.
II is nice to have on in the background but it doesn't stand up to scrutiny as well as the others.